Multivariate prediction of mixed, multilevel, sequential outcomes arising from in vitro fertilisation

10/20/2020
by   Jack Wilkinson, et al.
0

In vitro fertilization (IVF) comprises a sequence of interventions concerned with the creation and culture of embryos which are then transferred to the patient's uterus. While the clinically important endpoint is birth, the responses to each stage of treatment contain additional information about the reasons for success or failure. As such, the ability to predict not only the overall outcome of the cycle, but also the stage-specific responses, can be useful. This could be done by developing separate models for each response variable, but recent work has suggested that it may be advantageous to use a multivariate approach to model all outcomes simultaneously. Here, joint analysis of the sequential responses is complicated by mixed outcome types defined at two levels (patient and embryo). A further consideration is whether and how to incorporate information about the response at each stage in models for subsequent stages. We develop a case study using routinely collected data from a large reproductive medicine unit in order to investigate the feasibility and potential utility of multivariate prediction in IVF. We consider two possible scenarios. In the first, stage-specific responses are to be predicted prior to treatment commencement. In the second, responses are predicted dynamically, using the outcomes of previous stages as predictors. In both scenarios, we fail to observe benefits of joint modelling approaches compared to fitting separate regression models for each response variable.

READ FULL TEXT
POST COMMENT

Comments

There are no comments yet.

Authors

page 27

12/10/2020

Power prior models for treatment effect estimation in a small n, sequential, multiple assignment, randomized trial

A small n, sequential, multiple assignment, randomized trial (snSMART) i...
04/21/2021

Modeling sign concordance of quantile regression residuals with multiple outcomes

Quantile regression permits describing how quantiles of a scalar respons...
06/26/2020

Monitoring of process and risk-adjusted medical outcomes using a multi-stage MEWMA chart

Most statistical process control programmes in healthcare focus on surve...
01/21/2021

A unified method for multivariate mixed-type response regression

We propose a new method for multivariate response regressions where the ...
07/12/2019

Multilevel models for continuous outcomes

Multilevel models (mixed-effect models or hierarchical linear models) ar...
02/18/2021

A Generative Approach to Joint Modeling of Quantitative and Qualitative Responses

In many scientific areas, data with quantitative and qualitative (QQ) re...
10/16/2020

Generalized Co-sparse Factor Regression

Multivariate regression techniques are commonly applied to explore the a...
This week in AI

Get the week's most popular data science and artificial intelligence research sent straight to your inbox every Saturday.