Do Design Metrics Capture Developers Perception of Quality? An Empirical Study on Self-Affirmed Refactoring Activities

by   Eman Abdullah AlOmar, et al.

Background. Refactoring is a critical task in software maintenance and is generally performed to enforce the best design and implementation practices or to cope with design defects. Several studies attempted to detect refactoring activities through mining software repositories allowing to collect, analyze and get actionable data-driven insights about refactoring practices within software projects. Aim. We aim at identifying, among the various quality models presented in the literature, the ones that are more in-line with the developer's vision of quality optimization, when they explicitly mention that they are refactoring to improve them. Method. We extract a large corpus of design-related refactoring activities that are applied and documented by developers during their daily changes from 3,795 curated open source Java projects. In particular, we extract a large-scale corpus of structural metrics and anti-pattern enhancement changes, from which we identify 1,245 quality improvement commits with their corresponding refactoring operations, as perceived by software engineers. Thereafter, we empirically analyze the impact of these refactoring operations on a set of common state-of-the-art design quality metrics. Results. The statistical analysis of the obtained results shows that (i) a few state-of-the-art metrics are more popular than others; and (ii) some metrics are being more emphasized than others. Conclusions. We verify that there are a variety of structural metrics that can represent the internal quality attributes with different degrees of improvement and degradation of software quality. Most of the metrics that are mapped to the main quality attributes do capture developer intentions of quality improvement reported in the commit messages.


How Does API Migration Impact Software Quality and Comprehension? An Empirical Study

The migration process between different third-party software libraries i...

On the perceived relevance of critical internal quality attributes when evolving software features

Several refactorings performed while evolving software features aim to i...

Characterizing and Understanding Software Developer Networks in Security Development

To build secure software, developers often work together during software...

Unveiling process insights from refactoring practices

Context : Software comprehension and maintenance activities, such as ref...

Toward the Automatic Classification of Self-Affirmed Refactoring

The concept of Self-Affirmed Refactoring (SAR) was introduced to explore...

Just-in-Time Code Duplicates Extraction

Refactoring is a critical task in software maintenance, and is usually p...

Towards Software Analytics: Modeling Maintenance Activities

Lehman's Laws teach us that a software system will become progressively ...

Please sign up or login with your details

Forgot password? Click here to reset