Dislocated Accountabilities in the AI Supply Chain: Modularity and Developers' Notions of Responsibility

by   David Gray Widder, et al.

Responsible AI guidelines often ask engineers to consider how their systems might harm. However, contemporary AI systems are built by composing many preexisting software modules that pass through many hands before becoming a finished product or service. How does this shape responsible AI practice? In interviews with 27 AI engineers across industry, open source, and academia, our participants often did not see the questions posed in responsible AI guidelines to be within their agency, capability, or responsibility to address. We use Lucy Suchman's notion of located accountability to show how responsible AI labor is currently organized, and to explore how it could be done differently. We identify cross-cutting social logics, like modularizability, scale, reputation, and customer orientation, that organize which responsible AI actions do take place, and which are relegated to low status staff or believed to be the work of the next or previous person in the chain. We argue that current responsible AI interventions, like ethics checklists and guidelines that assume panoptical knowledge and control over systems, could improve by taking a located accountability approach, where relations and obligations intertwine and incrementally add value in the process. This would constitute a shift from "supply chain' thinking to "value chain" thinking.


A Method for Generating Dynamic Responsible AI Guidelines for Collaborative Action

To improve the development of responsible AI systems, developers are inc...

Five Ps: Leverage Zones Towards Responsible AI

There is a growing debate amongst academics and practitioners on whether...

Software Engineering for Responsible AI: An Empirical Study and Operationalised Patterns

Although artificial intelligence (AI) is solving real-world challenges a...

Thinking Upstream: Ethics and Policy Opportunities in AI Supply Chains

After children were pictured sewing its running shoes in the early 1990s...

Talkin' 'Bout AI Generation: Copyright and the Generative-AI Supply Chain

"Does generative AI infringe copyright?" is an urgent question. It is al...

Behavioral Use Licensing for Responsible AI

Scientific research and development relies on the sharing of ideas and a...

Unravelling Responsibility for AI

To reason about where responsibility does and should lie in complex situ...

Please sign up or login with your details

Forgot password? Click here to reset