Comparing Spatial Regression to Random Forests for Large Environmental Data Sets

12/26/2018
by   Eric W. Fox, et al.
0

Environmental data may be "large" due to number of records, number of covariates, or both. Random forests has a reputation for good predictive performance when using many covariates with nonlinear relationships, whereas spatial regression, when using reduced rank methods, has a reputation for good predictive performance when using many records that are spatially autocorrelated. In this study, we compare these two techniques using a data set containing the macroinvertebrate multimetric index (MMI) at 1859 stream sites with over 200 landscape covariates. A primary application is mapping MMI predictions and prediction errors at 1.1 million perennial stream reaches across the conterminous United States. For the spatial regression model, we develop a novel transformation procedure that estimates Box-Cox transformations to linearize covariate relationships and handles possibly zero-inflated covariates. We find that the spatial regression model with transformations, and a subsequent selection of significant covariates, has cross-validation performance slightly better than random forests. We also find that prediction interval coverage is close to nominal for each method, but that spatial regression prediction intervals tend to be narrower and have less variability than quantile regression forest prediction intervals. A simulation study is used to generalize results and clarify advantages of each modeling approach.

READ FULL TEXT

page 34

page 35

research
01/06/2021

Joint Variable Selection of both Fixed and Random Effects for Gaussian Process-based Spatially Varying Coefficient Models

Spatially varying coefficient (SVC) models are a type of regression mode...
research
05/31/2020

Ensemble Methods for Survival Data with Time-Varying Covariates

We propose two new survival forests for survival data with time-varying ...
research
12/23/2018

A Bayesian Zero-Inflated Negative Binomial Regression Model for the Integrative Analysis of Microbiome Data

Microbiome `omics approaches can reveal intriguing relationships between...
research
05/04/2021

Multi-resolution Spatial Regression for Aggregated Data with an Application to Crop Yield Prediction

We develop a new methodology for spatial regression of aggregated output...
research
04/23/2019

Regression-Enhanced Random Forests

Random forest (RF) methodology is one of the most popular machine learni...
research
12/14/2021

Zero-inflated Beta distribution regression modeling

A frequent challenge encountered with ecological data is how to interpre...
research
11/21/2021

Decorrelated Variable Importance

Because of the widespread use of black box prediction methods such as ra...

Please sign up or login with your details

Forgot password? Click here to reset