Combining Symbolic and Numeric Approaches to Uncertainty Management

by   Bruce D'Ambrosio, et al.

A complete approach to reasoning under uncertainty requires support for incremental and interactive formulation and revision of, as well as reasoning with, models of the problem domain capable of representing our uncertainty. We present a hybrid reasoning scheme which combines symbolic and numeric methods for uncertainty management to provide efficient and effective support for each of these tasks. The hybrid is based on symbolic techniques adapted from Assumption-based Truth Maintenance systems (ATMS), combined with numeric methods adapted from the Dempster/Shafer theory of evidence, as extended in Baldwin's Support Logic Programming system. The hybridization is achieved by viewing an ATMS as a symbolic algebra system for uncertainty calculations. This technique has several major advantages over conventional methods for performing inference with numeric certainty estimates in addition to the ability to dynamically determine hypothesis spaces, including improved management of dependent and partially independent evidence, faster run-time evaluation of propositional certainties, the ability to query the certainty value of a proposition from multiple perspectives, and the ability to incrementally extend or revise domain models.


page 1

page 2

page 3

page 4

page 5

page 6

page 7

page 8


Process, Structure, and Modularity in Reasoning with Uncertainty

Computational mechanisms for uncertainty management must support interac...

Reasoning in Non-Probabilistic Uncertainty: Logic Programming and Neural-Symbolic Computing as Examples

This article aims to achieve two goals: to show that probability is not ...

Probabilistic Assumption-Based Reasoning

The classical propositional assumption-based model is extended to incorp...

Symbolic Decision Theory and Autonomous Systems

The ability to reason under uncertainty and with incomplete information ...

Belief Maintenance in Bayesian Networks

Bayesian Belief Networks (BBNs) are a powerful formalism for reasoning u...

Effective Integration of Symbolic and Connectionist Approaches through a Hybrid Representation

In this paper, we present our position for a neuralsymbolic integration ...

Strong & Weak Methods: A Logical View of Uncertainty

The last few years has seen a growing debate about techniques for managi...