Automating Truth: The Case for Crowd-Powered Scientific Investigation in Economics

09/07/2018
by   Jorge Faleiro, et al.
0

Scientific investigation procedures have been evolving to follow an ever-changing cultural landscape, the sophistication of the technology available and an ever-growing knowledge base. This continuous evolution brought investigation practices through distinct historical phases, mostly marked by different types of participants and organization, from individual natural philosophers to science driven by large institutions. There is clear evidence that we are now getting to an age of drastic disruptive change. Increased complexity and mandatory multidisciplinary thinking have moved research from an initial phase of disjoint polymaths into a current phase of widespread uncontrolled use of computational tools and data generation, the "informatics crisis". The use of advanced computational technology for communication and generation of data in large scale without proper controls is compromising our ability to conduct an adequate reproducible investigation, causing a dangerous drift from the scientific method. To counteract this deviation, we advocate the use of a next-generation investigative approach leveraging forces of human diversity, micro-specialized crowds and proper computer-assisted control methods associated with a "pipeline of proof". This paper outlines the impact of advanced computational technology, not only as an accelerator of the rate in which humanity acquires objective knowledge but also as a dangerous side effect as a generator of massive amounts of uncontrolled, unverified and untraceable data and results that cannot be reproduced. We propose an alternative for methods of investigation based on collaboration in large-scale through standard procedures of proof and crowds in building a "collective brain in which neurons are human collaborators".

READ FULL TEXT
research
09/10/2023

Evolving landscape of US-China science collaboration: Convergence and divergence

International research collaboration among global scientific powerhouses...
research
09/20/2021

The Vision and the Perspective of Digital Tourism

The dynamics of the modern information society changes the usual areas o...
research
08/22/2023

Atlas of Science Collaboration, 1971-2020

The evolving landscape of interinstitutional collaborative research acro...
research
04/26/2022

Cross-media Scientific Research Achievements Query based on Ranking Learning

With the advent of the information age, the scale of data on the Interne...
research
09/19/2023

GPT4AIGChip: Towards Next-Generation AI Accelerator Design Automation via Large Language Models

The remarkable capabilities and intricate nature of Artificial Intellige...
research
02/15/2021

Self-Organizing Teams in Online Work Settings

As the volume and complexity of distributed online work increases, the c...
research
11/06/2019

Investigating Ortega Hypothesis in Q A portals: An Analysis of StackOverflow

Ortega Hypothesis considers masses, i.e., a large number of average peop...

Please sign up or login with your details

Forgot password? Click here to reset