An approach based on the geometric mean of basic quantitative and qualitative bibliometric indicators to evaluate and analyse the research performance of countries and institut

07/03/2018
by   Domingo Docampo, et al.
0

We present a straightforward procedure to evaluate the scientific contribution of territories and institutions that combines the size-dependent geometric mean, Q, of the number of research documents (N) and citations (C), and a scale-free measure of quality, q=C/N. We introduce a Global Research Output (GRO-index) as the geometric mean of Q and q. We show that the GRO-index correlates with the h-index, but appears to be more strongly correlated with other well known, widely used bibliometric indicators. We also compute relative GRO-indexes (GROr) associated with the scientific production within research fields. We note that although total sums of GROr values are larger than the GRO-index, due to the non-linearity in the computation of the geometric means, both counts are nevertheless highly correlated. That enables us to make useful comparative analyses among territories and institutions. Furthermore, to identify strengths and weaknesses of a given country or institution, we compute a Relative Research Output count (RROr-index) to tackle variations of the C/N ratio across research fields. Moreover, by using a wealth-index also based on quantitative and qualitative variables, we show that the GRO and RRO indexes are highly correlated with the wealth of the countries and the states of the USA. Given the simplicity of the procedures introduced in this paper and the fact that their results are easily understandable by non-specialists, we believe they could become as useful for the assessment of the research output of countries and institutions as the impact factor is for journals or the h-index for individuals.

READ FULL TEXT
POST COMMENT

Comments

There are no comments yet.

Authors

page 1

page 2

page 3

page 4

11/08/2018

h-index and its alternative: A Review

In recent years, several Scientometrics and Bibliometrics indicators wer...
12/20/2018

A new bibliometric approach to assess the scientific specialization of regions

The objective of the current work is to identify the territorial scienti...
09/16/2021

Quoka Atlas of Scholarly Knowledge Production: An Interactive Sensemaking Tool for Exploring the Outputs of Research Institutions

The vast amount of research produced at institutions world-wide is extre...
01/20/2021

A Robust Blockchain Readiness Index Model

As the blockchain ecosystem gets more mature many businesses, investors,...
06/06/2017

A two-dimensional index to quantify both scientific research impact and scope

Modern management of research is increasingly based on quantitative bibl...
11/05/2018

Bibliometric evaluation of research performance: where do we stand?

This work provides a critical examination of the most popular bibliometr...
03/16/2017

A modification to Hirsch index allowing comparisons across different scientific fields

The aim of this paper is to propose a simple modification to the origina...
This week in AI

Get the week's most popular data science and artificial intelligence research sent straight to your inbox every Saturday.