Wikipedia's Network Bias on Controversial Topics
share
The most important feature of Wikipedia is the presence of hyperlinks in pages. Link placement is the product of people's collaboration, consequently Wikipedia naturally inherits human bias. Due to the high influence that links' disposition has on users' navigation sessions, one needs to verify that, given a controversial topic, the hyperlinks' network does not expose users to only one side of the subject. A Wikipedia's topic-induced network that prevents users the discovery of different facets of an issue, suffers from structural bias. In this work, we define the static structural bias, which indicates if the strength of connections between pages of contrasting inclinations is the same, and the dynamic structural bias, which quantifies the network's level bias that users face over the course of their navigation sessions. Our measurements of structural bias on several controversial topics demonstrate its existence, revealing that users have low likelihood of reaching pages of opposing inclination from where they start, and that they navigate Wikipedia showing a behaviour much more biased than the expected from the baselines. Our findings advance the relevance of the problem and pave the way for developing systems that automatically measure and propose hyperlink locations that minimize the presence and effects of structural bias.
READ FULL TEXT