When confidence and competence collide: Effects on online decision-making discussions

by   Liye Fu, et al.

Group discussions are a way for individuals to exchange ideas and arguments in order to reach better decisions than they could on their own. One of the premises of productive discussions is that better solutions will prevail, and that the idea selection process is mediated by the (relative) competence of the individuals involved. However, since people may not know their actual competence on a new task, their behavior is influenced by their self-estimated competence --- that is, their confidence --- which can be misaligned with their actual competence. Our goal in this work is to understand the effects of confidence-competence misalignment on the dynamics and outcomes of discussions. To this end, we design a large-scale natural setting, in the form of an online team-based geography game, that allows us to disentangle confidence from competence and thus separate their effects. We find that in task-oriented discussions, the more-confident individuals have a larger impact on the group's decisions even when these individuals are at the same level of competence as their teammates. Furthermore, this unjustified role of confidence in the decision-making process often leads teams to under-perform. We explore this phenomenon by investigating the effects of confidence on conversational dynamics.


page 5

page 8


The Disparate Equilibria of Algorithmic Decision Making when Individuals Invest Rationally

The long-term impact of algorithmic decision making is shaped by the dyn...

Influence of the algorithm's reliability and transparency in the user's decision-making process

Algorithms have been becoming increasingly relevant for various decision...

Group Decisions based on Confidence Weighted Majority Voting

Background: It has repeatedly been reported that when making decisions u...

Conversational Markers of Constructive Discussions

Group discussions are essential for organizing every aspect of modern li...

Haptic communication optimises joint decisions and affords implicit confidence sharing

Group decisions can outperform the choices of the best individual group ...

Learning the Ranking of Causal Effects with Confounded Data

Decision makers often want to identify the individuals for whom some int...

Overcoming Temptation: Incentive Design For Intertemporal Choice

Individuals are often faced with temptations that can lead them astray f...

Please sign up or login with your details

Forgot password? Click here to reset