What Should We Optimize in Participatory Budgeting? An Experimental Study

11/14/2021
by   Ariel Rosenfeld, et al.
0

Participatory Budgeting (PB) is a process in which voters decide how to allocate a common budget; most commonly it is done by ordinary people – in particular, residents of some municipality – to decide on a fraction of the municipal budget. From a social choice perspective, existing research on PB focuses almost exclusively on designing computationally-efficient aggregation methods that satisfy certain axiomatic properties deemed "desirable" by the research community. Our work complements this line of research through a user study (N = 215) involving several experiments aimed at identifying what potential voters (i.e., non-experts) deem fair or desirable in simple PB settings. Our results show that some modern PB aggregation techniques greatly differ from users' expectations, while other, more standard approaches, provide more aligned results. We also identify a few possible discrepancies between what non-experts consider desirable and how they perceive the notion of "fairness" in the PB context. Taken jointly, our results can be used to help the research community identify appropriate PB aggregation methods to use in practice.

READ FULL TEXT

page 23

page 24

page 25

page 26

page 27

page 28

page 29

research
09/06/2020

Participatory Budgeting with Cumulative Votes

In participatory budgeting we are given a set of projects—each with a co...
research
11/02/2022

An Aggregation of Aggregation Methods in Computational Pathology

Image analysis and machine learning algorithms operating on multi-gigapi...
research
10/19/2020

Price of Fairness in Budget Division for Egalitarian Social Welfare

We study a participatory budgeting problem of aggregating the preference...
research
02/20/2015

A partial taxonomy of judgment aggregation rules, and their properties

The literature on judgment aggregation is moving from studying impossibi...
research
07/20/2023

Mitigating Voter Attribute Bias for Fair Opinion Aggregation

The aggregation of multiple opinions plays a crucial role in decision-ma...
research
09/11/2019

Sociotechnical Considerations for Accessible Visualization Design

Accessibility–the process of designing for people with disabilities (PWD...
research
03/31/2023

Understanding Journalists' Workflows in News Curation

With the increasing dominance of the internet as a source of news consum...

Please sign up or login with your details

Forgot password? Click here to reset