Using arguments for making decisions: A possibilistic logic approach

by   Leila Amgoud, et al.

Humans currently use arguments for explaining choices which are already made, or for evaluating potential choices. Each potential choice has usually pros and cons of various strengths. In spite of the usefulness of arguments in a decision making process, there have been few formal proposals handling this idea if we except works by Fox and Parsons and by Bonet and Geffner. In this paper we propose a possibilistic logic framework where arguments are built from an uncertain knowledge base and a set of prioritized goals. The proposed approach can compute two kinds of decisions by distinguishing between pessimistic and optimistic attitudes. When the available, maybe uncertain, knowledge is consistent, as well as the set of prioritized goals (which have to be fulfilled as far as possible), the method for evaluating decisions on the basis of arguments agrees with the possibility theory-based approach to decision-making under uncertainty. Taking advantage of its relation with formal approaches to defeasible argumentation, the proposed framework can be generalized in case of partially inconsistent knowledge, or goal bases.


page 1

page 2

page 3

page 4


A unified setting for inference and decision: An argumentation-based approach

Inferring from inconsistency and making decisions are two problems which...

Argumentative inference in uncertain and inconsistent knowledge bases

This paper presents and discusses several methods for reasoning from inc...

A formal framework for deliberated judgment

While the philosophical literature has extensively studied how decisions...

Decision Making under Uncertainty: A Quasimetric Approach

We propose a new approach for solving a class of discrete decision makin...

The Estimation of Subjective Probabilities via Categorical Judgments of Uncertainty

Theoretically as well as experimentally it is investigated how people re...

Decision Making with Argumentation Graphs

This work is about making decisions by digital means. Funds should be di...

Resolving Conflicting Arguments under Uncertainties

Distributed knowledge based applications in open domain rely on common s...