The Role of Pragmatics in Legal Norm Representation

by   Shashishekar Ramakrishna, et al.

Despite the 'apparent clarity' of a given legal provision, its application may result in an outcome that does not exactly conform to the semantic level of a statute. The vagueness within a legal text is induced intentionally to accommodate all possible scenarios under which such norms should be applied, thus making the role of pragmatics an important aspect also in the representation of a legal norm and reasoning on top of it. The notion of pragmatics considered in this paper does not focus on the aspects associated with judicial decision making. The paper aims to shed light on the aspects of pragmatics in legal linguistics, mainly focusing on the domain of patent law, only from a knowledge representation perspective. The philosophical discussions presented in this paper are grounded based on the legal theories from Grice and Marmor.



page 7


Multidimensionality of Legal Singularity: Parametric Analysis and the Autonomous Levels of AI Legal Reasoning

Legal scholars have in the last several years embarked upon an ongoing d...

Interpretable Low-Resource Legal Decision Making

Over the past several years, legal applications of deep learning have be...

Algorithmic audits of algorithms, and the law

Algorithmic decision making is now widespread, ranging from health care ...

When Exceptions are the Norm: Exploring the Role of Consent in HRI

HRI researchers have made major strides in developing robotic architectu...

Rule reasoning for legal norm validation of FSTP facts

Non-obviousness or inventive step is a general requirement for patentabi...

Assessing randomness in case assignment: the case study of the Brazilian Supreme Court

Sortition, i.e., random appointment for public duty, has been employed b...

Semantic Norm Recognition and its application to Portuguese Law

Being able to clearly interpret legal texts and fully understanding our ...
This week in AI

Get the week's most popular data science and artificial intelligence research sent straight to your inbox every Saturday.