The role of mainstreamness and interdisciplinarity for the relevance of scientific papers

10/08/2019
by   Stefan Thurner, et al.
0

There is demand from science funders, industry, and the public that science should become more risk-taking, more out-of-the-box, and more interdisciplinary. Is it possible to tell how interdisciplinary and out-of-the-box scientific papers are, or which papers are mainstream? Here we use the bibliographic coupling network, derived from all physics papers that were published in the Physical Review journals in the past century, to try to identify them as mainstream, out-of-the-box, or interdisciplinary. We show that the network clusters into scientific fields. The position of individual papers with respect to these clusters allows us to estimate their degree of mainstreamness or interdisciplinary. We show that over the past decades the fraction of mainstream papers increases, the fraction of out-of-the-box decreases, and the fraction of interdisciplinary papers remains constant. Studying the rewards of papers, we find that in terms of absolute citations, both, mainstream and interdisciplinary papers are rewarded. In the long run, mainstream papers perform less than interdisciplinary ones in terms of citation rates. We conclude that to avoid a trend towards mainstreamness a new incentive scheme is necessary.

READ FULL TEXT

page 1

page 2

page 3

page 4

research
02/24/2020

Uncited papers are not unread

We study citation dynamics of the Physics, Economics, and Mathematics pa...
research
09/21/2021

Generating Local Maps of Science using Deep Bibliographic Coupling

Bibliographic and co-citation coupling are two analytical methods widely...
research
06/18/2015

Comparing the writing style of real and artificial papers

Recent years have witnessed the increase of competition in science. Whil...
research
10/29/2018

Using Machine Learning to Predict the Evolution of Physics Research

The advancement of science as outlined by Popper and Kuhn is largely qua...
research
10/18/2019

How Coupled are Mass Spectrometry and Capillary Electrophoresis?

The understanding of how science works can contribute to making scientif...
research
10/16/2022

Consistency pays off in science

The exponentially growing number of scientific papers stimulates a discu...
research
07/28/2022

The decentralized evolution of decentralization across fields: from Governance to Blockchain

Decentralization is a widespread concept across disciplines such as Econ...

Please sign up or login with your details

Forgot password? Click here to reset