The Pragmatic Turn in Explainable Artificial Intelligence (XAI)

by   Andrés Páez, et al.

In this paper I argue that the search for explainable models and interpretable decisions in AI must be reformulated in terms of the broader project of offering a pragmatic and naturalistic account of understanding in AI. Intuitively, the purpose of providing an explanation of a model or a decision is to make it understandable to its stakeholders. But without a previous grasp of what it means to say that an agent understands a model or a decision, the explanatory strategies will lack a well-defined goal. Aside from providing a clearer objective for XAI, focusing on understanding also allows us to relax the factivity condition on explanation, which is impossible to fulfill in many machine learning models, and to focus instead on the pragmatic conditions that determine the best fit between a model and the methods and devices deployed to understand it. After an examination of the different types of understanding discussed in the philosophical and psychological literature, I conclude that interpretative or approximation models not only provide the best way to achieve the objectual understanding of a machine learning model, but are also a necessary condition to achieve post-hoc interpretability. This conclusion is partly based on the shortcomings of the purely functionalist approach to post-hoc interpretability that seems to be predominant in most recent literature.


page 1

page 2

page 3

page 4


What's meant by explainable model: A Scoping Review

We often see the term explainable in the titles of papers that describe ...

Predicting and Understanding Human Action Decisions during Skillful Joint-Action via Machine Learning and Explainable-AI

This study uses supervised machine learning (SML) and explainable artifi...

Comparison of attention models and post-hoc explanation methods for embryo stage identification: a case study

An important limitation to the development of AI-based solutions for In ...

Multicriteria interpretability driven Deep Learning

Deep Learning methods are renowned for their performances, yet their lac...

Toward Interpretable Machine Learning: Transparent Deep Neural Networks and Beyond

With the broader and highly successful usage of machine learning in indu...

Argumentative XAI: A Survey

Explainable AI (XAI) has been investigated for decades and, together wit...

Please sign up or login with your details

Forgot password? Click here to reset