The Natural Selection of Conservative Science

09/09/2019
by   Cailin O'Connor, et al.
0

Social epistemologists have argued that high risk, high reward science has an important role to play in scientific communities. Recently, though, it has also been argued that various scientific fields seem to be trending towards conservatism – the increasing production of what Kuhn (1970) would have called `normal science'. This paper will explore a possible explanation for this sort of trend: that the process by which scientific research groups form, grow, and dissolve might be inherently hostile to high risk science. In particular, I employ a paradigm developed by Smaldino and McElreath (2016) that treats a scientific community as a population undergoing selection. As will become clear, perhaps counter-intuitively this sort of process in some ways promotes high risk, high reward science. But, as I will point out, high risk high reward science is, in general, the sort of thing that is hard to repeat. While more conservative scientists will be able to train students capable of continuing their successful projects, and so create thriving lineages, successful risky science may not be the sort of thing one can easily pass on. In such cases, the structure of scientific communities selects against high risk, high rewards projects. More generally, this paper makes clear that there are at least two processes to consider in thinking about how incentives shape scientific communities – the process by which individual scientists make choices about their careers and research, and the selective process governing the formation of new research groups.

READ FULL TEXT
research
05/17/2022

Subdivisions and Crossroads: Identifying Hidden Community Structures in a Data Archive's Citation Network

Data archives are an important source of high quality data in many field...
research
02/12/2012

Citizen Science: Contributions to Astronomy Research

The contributions of everyday individuals to significant research has gr...
research
01/07/2021

Gender Imbalance and Spatiotemporal Patterns of Contributions to Citizen Science Projects: the case of Zooniverse

Citizen Science is research undertaken by professional scientists and me...
research
03/12/2020

Analysis of ResearchGate, A Community Detection Approach

We are living in the data age. Communications over scientific networks c...
research
11/14/2021

Metrics and Mechanisms: Measuring the Unmeasurable in the Science of Science

What science does, what science could do, and how to make science work? ...
research
02/01/2011

Emergence through Selection: The Evolution of a Scientific Challenge

One of the most interesting scientific challenges nowadays deals with th...
research
03/27/2018

Lisp, Jazz, Aikido -- Three Expressions of a Single Essence

The relation between Science (what we can explain) and Art (what we can'...

Please sign up or login with your details

Forgot password? Click here to reset