The Impact of Human Factors on the Participation Decision of Reviewers in Modern Code Review

06/27/2018
by   Shade Ruangwan, et al.
0

Modern Code Review (MCR) plays a key role in software quality practices. In MCR process, a new patch (i.e., a set of code changes) is encouraged to be examined by reviewers in order to identify weaknesses in source code prior to an integration into main software repositories. To mitigate the risk of having future defects, prior work suggests that MCR should be performed with sufficient review participation. Indeed, recent work shows that a low number of participated reviewers is associated with poor software quality. However, there is a likely case that a new patch still suffers from poor review participation even though reviewers were invited. Hence, in this paper, we set out to investigate the factors that are associated with the participation decision of an invited reviewer. Through a case study of 230,090 patches spread across the Android, LibreOffice, OpenStack and Qt systems, we find that (1) 16 patches have at least one invited reviewer who did not respond to the review invitation; (2) human factors play an important role in predicting whether or not an invited reviewer will participate in a review; (3) a review participation rate of an invited reviewers and code authoring experience of an invited reviewer are highly associated with the participation decision of an invited reviewer. These results can help practitioners better understand about how human factors associate with the participation decision of reviewers and serve as guidelines for inviting reviewers, leading to a better inviting decision and a better reviewer participation.

READ FULL TEXT
POST COMMENT

Comments

There are no comments yet.

Authors

page 36

03/15/2021

Does Code Review Promote Conformance? A Study of OpenStack Patches

Code Review plays a crucial role in software quality, by allowing review...
09/30/2021

Predicting Code Review Completion Time in Modern Code Review

Context. Modern Code Review (MCR) is being adopted in both open source a...
07/05/2018

Impact of Continuous Integration on Code Reviews

Peer code review and continuous integration often interleave with each o...
09/09/2019

A Systematic Review on Learning and Suggesting Source Code Changes in Version History

Software systems are in continuous evolution through source code changes...
06/04/2021

Automatic Patch Linkage Detection in Code Review Using TextualContent and File Location Features

Context: Contemporary code review tools are a popular choice for softwar...
04/04/2021

Code Reviews with Divergent Review Scores: An Empirical Study of the OpenStack and Qt Communities

Code review is a broadly adopted software quality practice where develop...
12/22/2018

An Industrial Case Study on Shrinking Code Review Changesets through Remark Prediction

Change-based code review is used widely in industrial software developme...
This week in AI

Get the week's most popular data science and artificial intelligence research sent straight to your inbox every Saturday.