The Forgotten Margins of AI Ethics

05/09/2022
by   Abeba Birhane, et al.
0

How has recent AI Ethics literature addressed topics such as fairness and justice in the context of continued social and structural power asymmetries? We trace both the historical roots and current landmark work that have been shaping the field and categorize these works under three broad umbrellas: (i) those grounded in Western canonical philosophy, (ii) mathematical and statistical methods, and (iii) those emerging from critical data/algorithm/information studies. We also survey the field and explore emerging trends by examining the rapidly growing body of literature that falls under the broad umbrella of AI Ethics. To that end, we read and annotated peer-reviewed papers published over the past four years in two premier conferences: FAccT and AIES. We organize the literature based on an annotation scheme we developed according to three main dimensions: whether the paper deals with concrete applications, use-cases, and/or people's lived experience; to what extent it addresses harmed, threatened, or otherwise marginalized groups; and if so, whether it explicitly names such groups. We note that although the goals of the majority of FAccT and AIES papers were often commendable, their consideration of the negative impacts of AI on traditionally marginalized groups remained shallow. Taken together, our conceptual analysis and the data from annotated papers indicate that the field would benefit from an increased focus on ethical analysis grounded in concrete use-cases, people's experiences, and applications as well as from approaches that are sensitive to structural and historical power asymmetries.

READ FULL TEXT

page 1

page 2

page 3

page 4

research
01/12/2021

What Do We Mean by "Accessibility Research"? A Literature Survey of Accessibility Papers in CHI and ASSETS from 1994 to 2019

Accessibility research has grown substantially in the past few decades, ...
research
09/21/2018

On Quantifying and Understanding the Role of Ethics in AI Research: A Historical Account of Flagship Conferences and Journals

Recent developments in AI, Machine Learning and Robotics have raised con...
research
08/02/2019

What is the Point of Fairness? Disability, AI and The Complexity of Justice

Work integrating conversations around AI and Disability is vital and val...
research
12/27/2020

An Ecosystem Approach to Ethical AI and Data Use: Experimental Reflections

While we have witnessed a rapid growth of ethics documents meant to guid...
research
07/18/2021

Desiderata for Explainable AI in statistical production systems of the European Central Bank

Explainable AI constitutes a fundamental step towards establishing fairn...
research
11/01/2020

AI Marker-based Large-scale AI Literature Mining

The knowledge contained in academic literature is interesting to mine. I...
research
09/18/2021

AI Accelerator Survey and Trends

Over the past several years, new machine learning accelerators were bein...

Please sign up or login with your details

Forgot password? Click here to reset