The Efficiency of Human Cognition Reflects Planned Information Processing

02/13/2020
by   Mark K Ho, et al.
7

Planning is useful. It lets people take actions that have desirable long-term consequences. But, planning is hard. It requires thinking about consequences, which consumes limited computational and cognitive resources. Thus, people should plan their actions, but they should also be smart about how they deploy resources used for planning their actions. Put another way, people should also "plan their plans". Here, we formulate this aspect of planning as a meta-reasoning problem and formalize it in terms of a recursive Bellman objective that incorporates both task rewards and information-theoretic planning costs. Our account makes quantitative predictions about how people should plan and meta-plan as a function of the overall structure of a task, which we test in two experiments with human participants. We find that people's reaction times reflect a planned use of information processing, consistent with our account. This formulation of planning to plan provides new insight into the function of hierarchical planning, state abstraction, and cognitive control in both humans and machines.

READ FULL TEXT

page 3

page 5

page 12

page 13

research
07/27/2020

Resource-rational Task Decomposition to Minimize Planning Costs

People often plan hierarchically. That is, rather than planning over a m...
research
07/13/2021

Encoding Compositionality in Classical Planning Solutions

Classical AI planners provide solutions to planning problems in the form...
research
07/25/2017

Physical problem solving: Joint planning with symbolic, geometric, and dynamic constraints

In this paper, we present a new task that investigates how people intera...
research
05/14/2021

Control of mental representations in human planning

One of the most striking features of human cognition is the capacity to ...
research
09/27/2017

The detour problem in a stochastic environment: Tolman revisited

We designed a grid world task to study human planning and re-planning be...
research
05/17/2019

The Unexpected Unexpected and the Expected Unexpected: How People's Conception of the Unexpected is Not That Unexpected

The answers people give when asked to 'think of the unexpected' for ever...
research
01/03/2022

Have I done enough planning or should I plan more?

People's decisions about how to allocate their limited computational res...

Please sign up or login with your details

Forgot password? Click here to reset