The Athena Class of Risk-Limiting Ballot Polling Audits

08/05/2020
by   Filip Zagorski, et al.
0

The main risk-limiting ballot polling audit in use today, BRAVO, is designed for use when single ballots are drawn at random and a decision regarding whether to stop the audit or draw another ballot is taken after each ballot draw (ballot-by-ballot (B2) audits). On the other hand, real ballot polling audits draw many ballots in a single round before determining whether to stop (round-by-round (R2) audits). We show that BRAVO results in significant inefficiency when directly applied to real R2 audits. We present the ATHENA class of R2 risk-limiting stopping rules, and prove that each rule is at least as efficient as the corresponding BRAVO stopping rule applied at the end of the round. We have software libraries implementing most of our results in both python and MATLAB. We show that ATHENA halves the number of ballots required, for all state margins in the 2016 US Presidential election and a first round with 90 stopping probability, when compared to BRAVO (stopping rule applied at the end of the round). We present simulation results supporting the 90 probability claims and our claims for the risk accrued in the first round. Further, ATHENA reduces the number of ballots by more than a quarter for low margins, when compared to the BRAVO stopping rule applied on ballots in selection order. This implies that keeping track of the order when drawing ballots R2 is not beneficial, because ATHENA is more efficient even without information on selection order. These results are significant because current approaches to real ballot polling election audits use the B2 BRAVO rules, requiring about twice as much work on the part of election officials. Many states performing risk-limiting audits for the first time plan to use ballot polling audits in November 2020 for the US Presidential election and could substantially benefit from improvements.

READ FULL TEXT
POST COMMENT

Comments

There are no comments yet.

Authors

page 1

page 2

page 3

page 4

02/04/2019

Risk-Limiting Bayesian Polling Audits for Two Candidate Elections

We propose a simple common framework for Risk-Limiting and Bayesian (pol...
01/09/2020

Adaptive Stopping Rule for Kernel-based Gradient Descent Algorithms

In this paper, we propose an adaptive stopping rule for kernel-based gra...
10/26/2021

On the consequences of draw restrictions in knockout tournaments

The paper analyses how draw constraints influence the outcome of a knock...
08/26/2020

Amortized Constant Round Atomic Snapshot in Message-Passing Systems

We study the lattice agreement (LA) and atomic snapshot problems in asyn...
10/02/2018

Odds for the Brazilian 2018 president elections: An application of Bayesian statistics in contingency tables

The purpose of these notes is to present an assessment of the probabilit...
04/03/2021

On the negative dependence inequalities and maximal score in round-robin tournament

We extend Huber's (1963) inequality for the joint distribution function ...
This week in AI

Get the week's most popular data science and artificial intelligence research sent straight to your inbox every Saturday.