Testing of Support Tools for Plagiarism Detection

by   Tomáš Foltýnek, et al.

There is a general belief that software must be able to easily do things that humans find difficult. Since finding sources for plagiarism in a text is not an easy task, there is a wide-spread expectation that it must be simple for software to determine if a text is plagiarized or not. Software cannot determine plagiarism, but it can work as a support tool for identifying some text similarity that may constitute plagiarism. But how well do the various systems work? This paper reports on a collaborative test of 15 web-based text-matching systems that can be used when plagiarism is suspected. It was conducted by researchers from seven countries using test material in eight different languages, evaluating the effectiveness of the systems on single-source and multi-source documents. A usability examination was also performed. The sobering results show that although some systems can indeed help identify some plagiarized content, they clearly do not find all plagiarism and at times also identify non-plagiarized material as problematic.


page 17

page 18

page 19

page 20

page 21

page 23

page 24

page 30


OSDG 2.0: a multilingual tool for classifying text data by UN Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs)

Despite concrete indicators and targets, monitoring the progress of the ...

Marvin: Semantic annotation using multiple knowledge sources

People are producing more written material then anytime in the history. ...

Quality Assurance of Bioinformatics Software: A Case Study of Testing a Biomedical Text Processing Tool Using Metamorphic Testing

Bioinformatics software plays a very important role in making critical d...

Understanding the Radical Mind: Identifying Signals to Detect Extremist Content on Twitter

The Internet and, in particular, Online Social Networks have changed the...

A Survey of User Expectations and Tool Limitations in Collaborative Scientific Authoring and Reviewing

Collaborative scientific authoring is increasingly being supported by so...

An assessment of orthographic similarity measures for several African languages

Natural Language Interfaces and tools such as spellcheckers and Web sear...

Tool Substitution with Shape and Material Reasoning Using Dual Neural Networks

This paper explores the problem of tool substitution, namely, identifyin...

Please sign up or login with your details

Forgot password? Click here to reset