Technical report for "Storage or No Storage: Duopoly Competition Between Renewable Energy Suppliers in a Local Energy Market"

by   Dongwei Zhao, et al.

This paper studies the duopoly competition between renewable energy suppliers with or without energy storage in a local energy market. The storage investment brings the benefits of stabilizing renewable energy suppliers' outputs, but it also leads to substantial investment costs as well as some surprising changes in the market outcome. To study the equilibrium decisions of storage investment in the renewable energy suppliers' competition, we model the interactions between suppliers and consumers using a three-stage game-theoretic model. In Stage I, at the beginning of the investment horizon, suppliers decide whether to invest in storage. Once such decisions have been made, in the day-ahead market of each day, suppliers decide on their bidding prices and quantities in Stage II, based on which consumers decide the electricity quantity purchased from each supplier in Stage III. In the real-time market, a supplier is penalized if his actual generation falls short of his commitment. We characterize a price-quantity competition equilibrium of Stage II, and we further characterize a storage-investment equilibrium in Stage I incorporating electricity-selling revenue and storage cost. Counter-intuitively, we show that the uncertainty of renewable energy without storage investment can lead to higher supplier profits compared with the stable generations with storage investment due to the reduced market competition under random energy generation. Simulations further illustrate results due to the market competition. For example, a higher penalty for not meeting the commitment, a higher storage cost, or a lower consumer demand can sometimes increase a supplier's profit. We also show that although storage investment can increase a supplier 's profit, the first-mover supplier who invests in storage may benefit less than the free-rider competitor who chooses not to invest.


page 1

page 2

page 3

page 4


Storage or No Storage: Duopoly Competition Between Renewable Energy Suppliers in a Local Energy Market

This paper studies the duopoly competition between renewable energy supp...

Technical report for "Virtual Energy Storage Sharing and Capacity Allocation"

Energy storage can play an important role in energy management of end us...

Sizing of a PV/Battery System Through Stochastic Control and Plant Aggregation

The objective of this work is to reduce the storage dimensions required ...

Duopoly Competition for Mobile Data Plans with Time Flexibility

The growing competition drives the mobile network operators (MNOs) to ex...

Selling Renewable Utilization Service to Consumers via Cloud Energy Storage

This paper proposes a cloud energy storage (CES) model for enabling loca...

Energy Storage Management via Deep Q-Networks

Energy storage devices represent environmentally friendly candidates to ...

On the Optimal Duration of Spectrum Leases in Exclusive License Markets with Stochastic Demand

This paper addresses the following question which is of interest in desi...

Please sign up or login with your details

Forgot password? Click here to reset