Systematic analysis of agreement between metrics and peer review in the UK REF

by   Vincent Traag, et al.

When performing a national research assessment, some countries rely on citation metrics whereas others, such as the UK, primarily use peer review. In the influential Metric Tide report, a low agreement between metrics and peer review in the UK Research Excellence Framework (REF) was found. However, earlier studies observed much higher agreement between metrics and peer review in the REF and argued in favour of using metrics. This shows that there is considerable ambiguity in the discussion on agreement between metrics and peer review. We provide clarity in this discussion by considering four important points: (1) the level of aggregation of the analysis; (2) the use of either a size-dependent or a size-independent perspective; (3) the suitability of different measures of agreement; and (4) the uncertainty in peer review. In the context of the REF, we argue that agreement between metrics and peer review should be assessed at the institutional level rather than at the publication level. Both a size-dependent and a size-independent perspective are relevant in the REF. The interpretation of correlations may be problematic and as an alternative we therefore use measures of agreement that are based on the absolute or relative differences between metrics and peer review. To get an idea of the uncertainty in peer review, we rely on a model to bootstrap peer review outcomes. We conclude that particularly in Physics, Clinical Medicine, and Public Health, metrics agree quite well with peer review and may offer an alternative to peer review.



There are no comments yet.


page 8


Metrics and peer review agreement at the institutional level

In the past decades, many countries have started to fund academic instit...

Peer review and citation data in predicting university rankings, a large-scale analysis

Most Performance-based Research Funding Systems (PRFS) draw on peer revi...

A novel data-driven algorithm to predict anomalous prescription based on patient's feature set

Appropriate dosing of radiation is crucial to patient safety in radiothe...

Agreement Maintenance Based on Schema and Ontology Change in P2P Environment

This paper is concern about developing a semantic agreement maintenance ...

Academics evaluating academics: a methodology to inform the review process on top of open citations

In the past, several works have investigated ways for combining quantita...

A Disciplinary View of Changes in Publications' Reference Lists After Peer Review

This paper provides insight into the changes manuscripts undergo during ...

Code Repositories


Replication material for analysis of UK REF 2014 results.

view repo
This week in AI

Get the week's most popular data science and artificial intelligence research sent straight to your inbox every Saturday.