Synthetic Interventions

by   Anish Agarwal, et al.

We develop a method to help quantify the impact different levels of mobility restrictions could have had on COVID-19 related deaths across nations. Synthetic control (SC) has emerged as a standard tool in such scenarios to produce counterfactual estimates if a particular intervention had not occurred, using just observational data. However, it remains an important open problem of how to extend SC to obtain counterfactual estimates if a particular intervention had occurred - this is exactly the question of the impact of mobility restrictions stated above. As our main contribution, we introduce synthetic interventions (SI), which helps resolve this open problem by allowing one to produce counterfactual estimates if there are multiple interventions of interest. We prove SI produces consistent counterfactual estimates under a tensor factor model. Our finite sample analysis shows the test error decays as 1/T_0, where T_0 is the amount of observed pre-intervention data. As a special case, this improves upon the 1/√(T_0) bound on test error for SC in prior works. Our test error bound holds under a certain "subspace inclusion" condition; we furnish a data-driven hypothesis test with provable guarantees to check for this condition. This also provides a quantitative hypothesis test for when to use SC, currently absent in the literature. Technically, we establish the parameter estimation and test error for Principal Component Regression (a key subroutine in SI and several SC variants) under the setting of error-in-variable regression decays as 1/T_0, where T_0 is the number of samples observed; this improves the best prior test error bound of 1/√(T_0). In addition to the COVID-19 case study, we show how SI can be used to run data-efficient, personalized randomized control trials using real data from a large e-commerce website and a large developmental economics study.


page 1

page 2

page 3

page 4


mRSC: Multi-dimensional Robust Synthetic Control

When evaluating the impact of a policy on a metric of interest, it may n...

Masks and COVID-19: a causal framework for imputing value to public-health interventions

During the COVID-19 pandemic, the scientific community developed predict...

Assessing the Sensitivity of Synthetic Control Treatment Effect Estimates to Misspecification Error

We propose a sensitivity analysis for Synthetic Control (SC) treatment e...

Adaptive Principal Component Regression with Applications to Panel Data

Principal component regression (PCR) is a popular technique for fixed-de...

Do We Exploit all Information for Counterfactual Analysis? Benefits of Factor Models and Idiosyncratic Correction

The measurement of treatment (intervention) effects on a single (or just...

Robust Synthetic Control

We present a robust generalization of the synthetic control method for c...

Please sign up or login with your details

Forgot password? Click here to reset