Success in creative careers depends little on product quality

05/15/2020
by   M. V. Simkin, et al.
0

In the recent article Janosov, Battiston, Sinatra report that they separated the inputs of talent and luck in creative careers. They build on the previous work of Sinatra et al which introduced the Q-model. Under the model the popularity of different elements of culture is a product of two factors: a random factor and a Qfactor, or talent. The latter is fixed for an individual but randomly distributed among different people. This way they explain how some individuals can consistently produce high-impact work. They extract the Q-factors for different scientists, writers, and movie makers from statistical data on popularity of their work. However, in their article they reluctantly state that there is little correlation between popularity and quality ratings of of books and movies (correlation coefficients 0.022 and 0.15). I analyzed the data of the original Q-factor article and obtained a correlation between the citation-based Q-factor and Nobel Prize winning of merely 0.19. I also briefly review few other experiments that found a meager, sometimes even negative, correlation between popularity and quality of cultural products. I conclude that, if there is an ability associated with a high Q-factor it should be more of a marketing ability than an ability to produce a higher quality product. Janosov,

READ FULL TEXT

page 1

page 2

page 3

page 4

research
09/13/2021

The correlation coefficient between citation metrics and winning a Nobel or Abel Prize

Computing such correlation coefficient would be straightforward had we h...
research
07/26/2022

Unique in what sense? Heterogeneous relationships between multiple types of uniqueness and popularity in music

How does our society appreciate the uniqueness of cultural products? Thi...
research
06/24/2021

Stochastic modeling of scientific impact

Recent research has found that select scientists have a disproportional ...
research
09/17/2019

Rotational Uniqueness Conditions Under Oblique Factor Correlation Metric

In an addendum to his seminal 1969 article Jöreskog stated two sets of c...
research
04/28/2022

Reconciling the Quality vs Popularity Dichotomy in Online Cultural Markets

We propose a simple model of an idealized online cultural market in whic...
research
03/23/2022

Exabel's Factor Model

Factor models have become a common and valued tool for understanding the...
research
10/28/2017

A Distributed Parallel Model to Analyze Journal Impact Factors

A simple abstract model is developed as a parallel experimental basis fo...

Please sign up or login with your details

Forgot password? Click here to reset