Structural Similarity Index SSIMplified: Is there really a simpler concept at the heart of image quality measurement?

01/29/2015
by   Kieran Gerard Larkin, et al.
0

The Structural Similarity Index (SSIM) is generally considered to be a milestone in the recent history of Image Quality Assessment (IQA). Alas, SSIM's accepted development from the product of three heuristic factors continues to obscure it's real underlying simplicity. Starting instead from a symmetric-antisymmetric reformulation we first show SSIM to be a contrast or visibility function in the classic sense. Furthermore, the previously enigmatic structural covariance is revealed to be the difference of variances. The second step, eliminating the intrinsic quadratic nature of SSIM, allows a near linear correlation with human observer scores, and without invoking the usual, but arbitrary, sigmoid model fitting. We conclude that SSIM can be re-interpreted in terms of perceptual masking: it is essentially equivalent to a normalised error or noise visibility function (NVF), and, furthermore, the NVF alone explains it success in modelling perceptual image quality. We use the term Dissimilarity Quotient (DQ) for the specifically anti/symmetric SSIM derived NVF. It seems that IQA researchers may now have two choices: 1) Continue to use the complex SSIM formula, but noting that SSIM only works coincidentally since the covariance term is actually the mean square error (MSE) in disguise. 2) Use the simplest of all perceptually-masked image quality metrics, namely NVF or DQ. On this choice Occam is clear: in the absence of differences in predictive ability, the fewer assumptions that are made, the better.

READ FULL TEXT
research
11/22/2018

Image Quality Assessment and Color Difference

An average healthy person does not perceive the world in just black and ...
research
08/22/2017

Contrast and visual saliency similarity induced index for image quality assessment

Perceptual image quality assessment (IQA) defines/utilizes a computation...
research
01/19/2021

Ambiguity of Objective Image Quality Metrics: A New Methodology for Performance Evaluation

Objective image quality metrics try to estimate the perceptual quality o...
research
10/16/2021

Locally Adaptive Structure and Texture Similarity for Image Quality Assessment

The latest advances in full-reference image quality assessment (IQA) inv...
research
06/24/2020

Understanding SSIM

The use of the structural similarity index (SSIM) is widespread. For alm...
research
10/21/2022

Task-Based Assessment for Neural Networks: Evaluating Undersampled MRI Reconstructions based on Human Observer Signal Detection

Recent research has explored using neural networks to reconstruct unders...
research
03/11/2018

Learning Local Distortion Visibility From Image Quality Data-sets

Accurate prediction of local distortion visibility thresholds is critica...

Please sign up or login with your details

Forgot password? Click here to reset