See further upon the giants: Quantifying intellectual lineage in science

02/16/2022
by   Woo Seong Jo, et al.
0

Newton's centuries-old wisdom of standing on the shoulders of giants raises a crucial yet underexplored question: Out of all the prior works cited by a discovery, which one is its giant? Here, we develop a novel, discipline-independent method to identify the giant for any individual paper, allowing us to systematically examine the role and characteristics of giants in science. We find that across disciplines, about 95 shoulders of giants, yet the weight of scientific progress rests on relatively few shoulders. Defining a new measure of giant index, we find that, while papers with high citations are more likely to be giants, for papers with the same citations, their giant index sharply predicts a paper's future impact and prize-winning probabilities. Giants tend to originate from both small and large teams, being either highly disruptive or highly developmental. And papers that did not have a giant but later became a giant tend to be home-run papers that are highly disruptive to science. Given the crucial importance of citation-based measures in science, the developed concept of giants may offer a useful new dimension in assessing scientific impact that goes beyond sheer citation counts.

READ FULL TEXT
research
01/30/2023

Citation Analysis of Computer Systems Papers

Citation analysis is used extensively in the bibliometrics literature to...
research
10/16/2022

Consistency pays off in science

The exponentially growing number of scientific papers stimulates a discu...
research
06/24/2021

Stochastic modeling of scientific impact

Recent research has found that select scientists have a disproportional ...
research
02/08/2022

Quantifying the topic disparity of scientific articles

Citation count is a popular index for assessing scientific papers. Howev...
research
12/27/2018

Identifying translational science through embeddings of controlled vocabularies

Objective: Translational science aims at "translating" basic scientific ...
research
03/26/2023

Interdisciplinary Papers Supported by Disciplinary Grants Garner Deep and Broad Scientific Impact

Interdisciplinary research has emerged as a hotbed for innovation and di...
research
04/15/2021

La evaluacion de la investigacion: Espana suspende

The research assessments of countries or institutions should reveal thei...

Please sign up or login with your details

Forgot password? Click here to reset