Quantifying incentive (in)compatibility: a case study from sports

04/07/2021
by   László Csató, et al.
0

Incentive compatibility is usually considered a binary concept in the academic literature. Our paper aims to present a method for quantifying the violation of strategy-proofness in the case of sports tournaments, in particular, through the example of the European Qualifiers for the 2022 FIFA World Cup. Even though that competition is known to be vulnerable to manipulation since certain teams might be interested in the success of other teams, the extent of the problem has remained unexplored until now. Based on computer simulations, the strategic behaviour of the contestants is found to have non-negligible sporting effects. While strategy-proofness cannot be guaranteed without fundamentally changing the tournament design, we can substantially mitigate this threat by adding a carefully chosen set of draw restrictions, which offers a justifiable and transparent solution to improve fairness. Sports governing bodies are encouraged to take our findings into account.

READ FULL TEXT

page 8

page 12

research
05/08/2019

The unfairness of the UEFA Euro 2020 qualifying

The qualification for the UEFA European Championship 2020 is strongly co...
research
03/21/2021

Analysing the restricted assignment problem of the group draw in sports tournaments

Many sports tournaments contain a group stage where the allocation of te...
research
01/28/2020

Bounded Incentives in Manipulating the Probabilistic Serial Rule

The Probabilistic Serial mechanism is well-known for its desirable fairn...
research
09/28/2021

Fairer group draw for sports tournaments with restrictions

Some recent sports tournaments establish restrictions in the draw of the...
research
02/15/2021

RPPLNS: Pay-per-last-N-shares with a Randomised Twist

"Pay-per-last-N-shares" (PPLNS) is one of the most common payout strateg...
research
11/12/2019

Incentive Compatible Active Learning

We consider active learning under incentive compatibility constraints. T...
research
12/14/2019

Why is the current seeding regime of the UEFA Champions League unfair?

Fairness has several interpretations in sports, one of them being that t...

Please sign up or login with your details

Forgot password? Click here to reset