Provenance-Based Assessment of Plans in Context

11/03/2020
by   Scott E. Friedman, et al.
0

Many real-world planning domains involve diverse information sources, external entities, and variable-reliability agents, all of which may impact the confidence, risk, and sensitivity of plans. Humans reviewing a plan may lack context about these factors; however, this information is available during the domain generation, which means it can also be interwoven into the planner and its resulting plans. This paper presents a provenance-based approach to explaining automated plans. Our approach (1) extends the SHOP3 HTN planner to generate dependency information, (2) transforms the dependency information into an established PROV-O representation, and (3) uses graph propagation and TMS-inspired algorithms to support dynamic and counter-factual assessment of information flow, confidence, and support. We qualified our approach's explanatory scope with respect to explanation targets from the automated planning literature and the information analysis literature, and we demonstrate its ability to assess a plan's pertinence, sensitivity, risk, assumption support, diversity, and relative confidence.

READ FULL TEXT

page 3

page 6

page 7

research
03/09/2000

Planning with Incomplete Information

Planning is a natural domain of application for frameworks of reasoning ...
research
03/06/2013

A Method for Planning Given Uncertain and Incomplete Information

This paper describes ongoing research into planning in an uncertain envi...
research
08/01/2017

Balancing Explicability and Explanation in Human-Aware Planning

Human aware planning requires an agent to be aware of the intentions, ca...
research
09/13/2017

Workflow Complexity for Collaborative Interactions: Where are the Metrics? -- A Challenge

In this paper, we introduce the problem of denoting and deriving the com...
research
05/14/2021

A feasibility study of a hyperparameter tuning approach to automated inverse planning in radiotherapy

Radiotherapy inverse planning requires treatment planners to modify mult...
research
11/08/2020

Provenance-Based Interpretation of Multi-Agent Information Analysis

Analytic software tools and workflows are increasing in capability, comp...
research
04/27/2010

On the comparison of plans: Proposition of an instability measure for dynamic machine scheduling

On the basis of an analysis of previous research, we present a generaliz...

Please sign up or login with your details

Forgot password? Click here to reset