Prophet Inequality with Competing Agents

by   Tomer Ezra, et al.

We introduce a model of competing agents in a prophet setting, where rewards arrive online, and decisions are made immediately and irrevocably. The rewards are unknown from the outset, but they are drawn from a known probability distribution. In the standard prophet setting, a single agent makes selection decisions in an attempt to maximize her expected reward. The novelty of our model is the introduction of a competition setting, where multiple agents compete over the arriving rewards, and make online selection decisions simultaneously, as rewards arrive. If a given reward is selected by more than a single agent, ties are broken either randomly or by a fixed ranking of the agents. The consideration of competition turns the prophet setting from an online decision making scenario to a multi-agent game. For both random and ranked tie-breaking rules, we present simple threshold strategies for the agents that give them high guarantees, independent of the strategies taken by others. In particular, for random tie-breaking, every agent can guarantee herself at least 1/k+1 of the highest reward, and at least 1/2k of the optimal social welfare. For ranked tie-breaking, the ith ranked agent can guarantee herself at least a half of the ith highest reward. We complement these results by matching upper bounds, even with respect to equilibrium profiles. For ranked tie-breaking rule, we also show a correspondence between the equilibrium of the k-agent game and the optimal strategy of a single decision maker who can select up to k rewards.


page 1

page 2

page 3

page 4


On a Competitive Secretary Problem with Deferred Selections

We study secretary problems in settings with multiple agents. In the sta...

On the Complexity of Multi-Agent Decision Making: From Learning in Games to Partial Monitoring

A central problem in the theory of multi-agent reinforcement learning (M...

Multi-agent Time-based Decision-making for the Search and Action Problem

Many robotic applications, such as search-and-rescue, require multiple a...

Reinforcement with Fading Memories

We study the effect of imperfect memory on decision making in the contex...

Competitive Safety Analysis: Robust Decision-Making in Multi-Agent Systems

Much work in AI deals with the selection of proper actions in a given (k...

Liquid Democracy with Ranked Delegations

Liquid democracy is a novel paradigm for collective decision-making that...

Strategic Inference with a Single Private Sample

Motivated by applications in cyber security, we develop a simple game mo...

Please sign up or login with your details

Forgot password? Click here to reset