Proactive Moderation of Online Discussions: Existing Practices and the Potential for Algorithmic Support

11/29/2022
by   Charlotte Schluger, et al.
0

To address the widespread problem of uncivil behavior, many online discussion platforms employ human moderators to take action against objectionable content, such as removing it or placing sanctions on its authors. This reactive paradigm of taking action against already-posted antisocial content is currently the most common form of moderation, and has accordingly underpinned many recent efforts at introducing automation into the moderation process. Comparatively less work has been done to understand other moderation paradigms – such as proactively discouraging the emergence of antisocial behavior rather than reacting to it – and the role algorithmic support can play in these paradigms. In this work, we investigate such a proactive framework for moderation in a case study of a collaborative setting: Wikipedia Talk Pages. We employ a mixed methods approach, combining qualitative and design components for a holistic analysis. Through interviews with moderators, we find that despite a lack of technical and social support, moderators already engage in a number of proactive moderation behaviors, such as preemptively intervening in conversations to keep them on track. Further, we explore how automation could assist with this existing proactive moderation workflow by building a prototype tool, presenting it to moderators, and examining how the assistance it provides might fit into their workflow. The resulting feedback uncovers both strengths and drawbacks of the prototype tool and suggests concrete steps towards further developing such assisting technology so it can most effectively support moderators in their existing proactive moderation workflow.

READ FULL TEXT

page 1

page 3

page 11

research
12/02/2022

Thread With Caution: Proactively Helping Users Assess and Deescalate Tension in Their Online Discussions

Incivility remains a major challenge for online discussion platforms, to...
research
07/19/2019

Liger: Combining Interaction Paradigms for Visual Analysis

Visualization tools usually leverage a single interaction paradigm (e.g....
research
02/13/2021

ADEPT: A Socio-Technical Theory of Continuous Integration

Continuous practices that rely on automation in the software development...
research
10/22/2018

The Lives of Bots

Automated software agents --- or bots --- have long been an important pa...
research
05/04/2020

Crafting, Communality, and Computing: Building on Existing Strengths To Support a Vulnerable Population

In Nepal, sex-trafficking survivors and the organizations that support t...
research
07/07/2017

Computational Models of Tutor Feedback in Language Acquisition

This paper investigates the role of tutor feedback in language learning ...
research
04/27/2019

Towards Automation of Creativity: A Machine Intelligence Approach

This paper demonstrates emergence of computational creativity in the fie...

Please sign up or login with your details

Forgot password? Click here to reset