Log In Sign Up

Preferential Structures for Comparative Probabilistic Reasoning

by   Matthew Harrison-Trainor, et al.

Qualitative and quantitative approaches to reasoning about uncertainty can lead to different logical systems for formalizing such reasoning, even when the language for expressing uncertainty is the same. In the case of reasoning about relative likelihood, with statements of the form φ≿ψ expressing that φ is at least as likely as ψ, a standard qualitative approach using preordered preferential structures yields a dramatically different logical system than a quantitative approach using probability measures. In fact, the standard preferential approach validates principles of reasoning that are incorrect from a probabilistic point of view. However, in this paper we show that a natural modification of the preferential approach yields exactly the same logical system as a probabilistic approach–not using single probability measures, but rather sets of probability measures. Thus, the same preferential structures used in the study of non-monotonic logics and belief revision may be used in the study of comparative probabilistic reasoning based on imprecise probabilities.


page 1

page 2

page 3

page 4


Logical Probability Preferences

We present a unified logical framework for representing and reasoning ab...

Compatibility of Quantitative and Qualitative Representations of Belief

The compatibility of quantitative and qualitative representations of bel...

On Non-monotonic Conditional Reasoning

This note is concerned with a formal analysis of the problem of non-mono...

Generalized Qualitative Probability: Savage Revisited

Preferences among acts are analyzed in the style of L. Savage, but as pa...

Weighted regret-based likelihood: a new approach to describing uncertainty

Recently, Halpern and Leung suggested representing uncertainty by a weig...

Plausibility Measures and Default Reasoning

We introduce a new approach to modeling uncertainty based on plausibilit...

Syntax-based Default Reasoning as Probabilistic Model-based Diagnosis

We view the syntax-based approaches to default reasoning as a model-base...