Planning a method for covariate adjustment in individually-randomised trials: a practical guide

07/13/2021
by   Tim P Morris, et al.
0

Background: It has long been advised to account for baseline covariates in the analysis of confirmatory randomised trials, with the main statistical justifications being that this increases power and, when a randomisation scheme balanced covariates, permits a valid estimate of experimental error. There are various methods available to account for covariates. Methods: We consider how, at the point of writing a statistical analysis plan, to choose between three broad approaches: direct adjustment, standardisation and inverse-probability-of-treatment weighting (IPTW), which are in our view the most promising methods. Using the GetTested trial, a randomised trial designed to assess the effectiveness of an electonic STI (sexually transmitted infection) testing and results service, we illustrate how a method might be chosen in advance and show some of the anticipated issues in action. Results: The choice of approach is not straightforward, particularly with models for binary outcome measures, where we focus most of our attention. We compare the properties of the three broad approaches in terms of the quantity they target (estimand), how a method performs under model misspecification, convergence issues, handling designed balance, precision of estimators, estimation of standard errors, and finally clarify some issues around handling of missing data. Conclusions: We conclude that no single approach is always best and explain why the choice will depend on the trial context but encourage trialists to consider the three methods more routinely.

READ FULL TEXT
research
12/19/2022

Prognostic Covariate Adjustment for Binary Outcomes Using Stratification

Covariate adjustment and methods of incorporating historical data in ran...
research
12/17/2022

Covariate Adjustment in Bayesian Adaptive Clinical Trials

In conventional randomized controlled trials, adjustment for baseline va...
research
06/24/2022

Accounting for Inconsistent Use of Covariate Adjustment in Group Sequential Trials

Group sequential designs are common in clinical trials, as they allow fo...
research
02/03/2021

Covariate adjustment in subgroup analyses of randomized clinical trials: A propensity score approach

Background: Subgroup analyses are frequently conducted in randomized cli...
research
05/18/2018

Pitfalls of adjusting for mean baseline utilities/costs in trial-based cost-effectiveness analysis with missing data

Failure to account for baseline utilities/costs imbalance between treatm...
research
07/15/2021

Covariate adjustment in randomised trials: canonical link functions protect against model mis-specification

Covariate adjustment has the potential to increase power in the analysis...
research
05/21/2019

Robustness of ANCOVA in randomised trials with unequal randomisation

Randomised trials with continuous outcomes are often analysed using ANCO...

Please sign up or login with your details

Forgot password? Click here to reset