DeepAI AI Chat
Log In Sign Up

Over-representation of Extreme Events in Decision-Making: A Rational Metacognitive Account

by   Ardavan S. Nobandegani, et al.
McGill University

The Availability bias, manifested in the over-representation of extreme eventualities in decision-making, is a well-known cognitive bias, and is generally taken as evidence of human irrationality. In this work, we present the first rational, metacognitive account of the Availability bias, formally articulated at Marr's algorithmic level of analysis. Concretely, we present a normative, metacognitive model of how a cognitive system should over-represent extreme eventualities, depending on the amount of time available at its disposal for decision-making. Our model also accounts for two well-known framing effects in human decision-making under risk---the fourfold pattern of risk preferences in outcome probability (Tversky & Kahneman, 1992) and in outcome magnitude (Markovitz, 1952)---thereby providing the first metacognitively-rational basis for those effects. Empirical evidence, furthermore, confirms an important prediction of our model. Surprisingly, our model is unimaginably robust with respect to its focal parameter. We discuss the implications of our work for studies on human decision-making, and conclude by presenting a counterintuitive prediction of our model, which, if confirmed, would have intriguing implications for human decision-making under risk. To our knowledge, our model is the first metacognitive, resource-rational process model of cognitive biases in decision-making.


page 3

page 5


Morshed: Guiding Behavioral Decision-Makers towards Better Security Investment in Interdependent Systems

We model the behavioral biases of human decision-making in securing inte...

Economics and Optimal Investment Policies of Attackers and Defenders in Cybersecurity

In our time cybersecurity has grown to be a topic of massive proportion ...

Can Language Representation Models Think in Bets?

In recent years, transformer-based language representation models (LRMs)...

Hierarchical Modeling of Seed Variety Yields and Decision Making for Future Planting Plans

Eradicating hunger and malnutrition is a key development goal of the 21s...

Decision Making "Biases" and Support for Assumption-Based Higher-Order Reasoning

Unaided human decision making appears to systematically violate consiste...

On the Causes and Consequences of Deviations from Rational Behavior

This paper presents novel evidence for the prevalence of deviations from...

Probabilistic Formulation of the Take The Best Heuristic

The framework of cognitively bounded rationality treats problem solving ...