DeepAI AI Chat
Log In Sign Up

Origins of Algorithmic Instabilities in Crowdsourced Ranking

by   Keith Burghardt, et al.

Crowdsourcing systems aggregate decisions of many people to help users quickly identify high-quality options, such as the best answers to questions or interesting news stories. A long-standing issue in crowdsourcing is how option quality and human judgement heuristics interact to affect collective outcomes, such as the perceived popularity of options. We address this limitation by conducting a controlled experiment where subjects choose between two ranked options whose quality can be independently varied. We use this data to construct a model that quantifies how judgement heuristics and option quality combine when deciding between two options. The model reveals popularity-ranking can be unstable: unless the quality difference between the two options is sufficiently high, the higher quality option is not guaranteed to be eventually ranked on top. To rectify this instability, we create an algorithm that accounts for judgement heuristics to infer the best option and rank it first. This algorithm is guaranteed to be optimal if data matches the model. When the data does not match the model, however, simulations show that in practice this algorithm performs better or at least as well as popularity-based and recency-based ranking for any two-choice question. Our work suggests that algorithms relying on inference of mathematical models of user behavior can substantially improve outcomes in crowdsourcing systems.


page 1

page 2

page 3

page 4


Option-Driven Design: Context, Tradeoffs, and Considerations for Accessibility

In Option-Driven Design, users must interact with options and settings f...

Optimal Options for Multi-Task Reinforcement Learning Under Time Constraints

Reinforcement learning can greatly benefit from the use of options as a ...

Delegated Online Search

In a delegation problem, a principal P with commitment power tries to pi...

Quantifying the Impact of Cognitive Biases in Question-Answering Systems

Crowdsourcing can identify high-quality solutions to problems; however, ...

Option Comparison Network for Multiple-choice Reading Comprehension

Multiple-choice reading comprehension (MCRC) is the task of selecting th...

Relaxed forced choice improves performance of visual quality assessment methods

In image quality assessment, a collective visual quality score for an im...

Breaking indecision in multi-agent, multi-option dynamics

How does a group of agents break indecision when deciding about options ...