On the Strategyproofness of the Geometric Median

06/04/2021
by   El Mahdi El Mhamdi, et al.
0

The geometric median of a tuple of vectors is the vector that minimizes the sum of Euclidean distances to the vectors of the tuple. Interestingly, the geometric median can also be viewed as the equilibrium of a process where each vector of the tuple pulls on a common decision point with a unitary force towards them, promoting the "one voter, one unit force" fairness principle. In this paper, we analyze the strategyproofness of the geometric median as a voting system. Assuming that voters want to minimize the Euclidean distance between their preferred vector and the outcome of the vote, we first prove that, in the general case, the geometric median is not even α-strategyproof. However, in the limit of a large number of voters, assuming that voters' preferred vectors are drawn i.i.d. from a distribution of preferred vectors, we also prove that the geometric median is asymptotically α-strategyproof. The bound α describes what a voter can gain (at most) by deviating from truthfulness. We show how to compute this bound as a function of the distribution followed by the vectors. We then generalize our results to the case where each voter actually cares more about some dimensions rather than others. Roughly, we show that, if some dimensions are more polarized and regarded as more important, then the geometric median becomes less strategyproof. Interestingly, we also show how the skewed geometric medians can be used to improve strategyproofness. Nevertheless, if voters care differently about different dimensions, we prove that no skewed geometric median can achieve strategyproofness for all of them. Overall, our results provide insight into the extent to which the (skewed) geometric median is a suitable approach to aggregate high-dimensional disagreements.

READ FULL TEXT
12/01/2021

On the Complexity of the Geometric Median Problem with Outliers

In the Geometric Median problem with outliers, we are given a finite set...
10/29/2018

Geometric Median Shapes

We present an algorithm to compute the geometric median of shapes which ...
11/03/2017

The Bane of Low-Dimensionality Clustering

In this paper, we give a conditional lower bound of n^Ω(k) on running ti...
11/09/2020

Hardness of Approximation of Euclidean k-Median

The Euclidean k-median problem is defined in the following manner: given...
07/10/2018

A Curious Result on Breaking Ties among Sample Medians

It is well known that any sample median value (not necessarily unique) m...
07/12/2012

Non-Local Euclidean Medians

In this letter, we note that the denoising performance of Non-Local Mean...
02/28/2019

Probabilistic smallest enclosing ball in high dimensions via subgradient sampling

We study a variant of the median problem for a collection of point sets ...