On the Intrinsic Redundancy in Huge Natural Deduction proofs II: Analysing M_ Super-Polynomial Proofs

09/17/2020
by   Edward Hermann Haeusler, et al.
0

This article precisely defines huge proofs within the system of Natural Deduction for the Minimal implicational propositional logic . This is what we call an unlimited family of super-polynomial proofs. We consider huge families of expanded normal form mapped proofs, a device to explicitly help to count the E-parts of a normal proof in an adequate way. Thus, we show that for almost all members of a super-polynomial family there at least one sub-proof or derivation of each of them that is repeated super-polynomially many times. This last property we call super-polynomial redundancy. Almost all, precisely means that there is a size of the conclusion of proofs that every proof with conclusion bigger than this size and that is huge is highly redundant too. This result points out to a refinement of compression methods previously presented and an alternative and simpler proof that CoNP=NP.

READ FULL TEXT

page 1

page 2

page 3

page 4

research
12/11/2020

Going from the huge to the small: Efficient succinct representation of proofs in Minimal implicational logic

A previous article shows that any linear height bounded normal proof of ...
research
12/28/2020

Yet another argument in favour of NP=CoNP

This article shows yet another proof of NP=CoNP. In a previous article, ...
research
03/16/2020

Exponentially Huge Natural Deduction proofs are Redundant: Preliminary results on M_⊃

We estimate the size of a labelled tree by comparing the amount of (labe...
research
06/06/2022

On the horizontal compression of dag-derivations in minimal purely implicational logic

In this report, we define (plain) Dag-like derivations in the purely imp...
research
04/10/2021

Information in propositional proofs and algorithmic proof search

We study from the proof complexity perspective the (informal) proof sear...
research
04/28/2021

Kernelization, Proof Complexity and Social Choice

We display an application of the notions of kernelization and data reduc...
research
04/02/2023

Ruling Out Short Proofs of Unprovable Sentences is Hard

If no optimal propositional proof system exists, we (and independently P...

Please sign up or login with your details

Forgot password? Click here to reset