On the Intertranslatability of Argumentation Semantics

01/16/2014
by   Wolfgang Dvorák, et al.
0

Translations between different nonmonotonic formalisms always have been an important topic in the field, in particular to understand the knowledge-representation capabilities those formalisms offer. We provide such an investigation in terms of different semantics proposed for abstract argumentation frameworks, a nonmonotonic yet simple formalism which received increasing interest within the last decade. Although the properties of these different semantics are nowadays well understood, there are no explicit results about intertranslatability. We provide such translations wrt. different properties and also give a few novel complexity results which underlie some negative results.

READ FULL TEXT

page 1

page 2

page 3

page 4

research
04/26/2021

Relational Argumentation Semantics

In this paper, we propose a fresh perspective on argumentation semantics...
research
02/04/2021

Aggregating Bipolar Opinions (With Appendix)

We introduce a novel method to aggregate Bipolar Argumentation (BA) Fram...
research
07/04/2016

Understanding the Abstract Dialectical Framework (Preliminary Report)

Among the most general structures extending the framework by Dung are th...
research
03/02/2020

On the Existence of Characterization Logics and Fundamental Properties of Argumentation Semantics

Given the large variety of existing logical formalisms it is of utmost i...
research
05/06/2022

Rediscovering Argumentation Principles Utilizing Collective Attacks

Argumentation Frameworks (AFs) are a key formalism in AI research. Their...
research
12/10/2020

Interpreting Neural Networks as Gradual Argumentation Frameworks (Including Proof Appendix)

We show that an interesting class of feed-forward neural networks can be...
research
09/12/2023

Games and Argumentation: Time for a Family Reunion!

The rule "defeated(X) ← attacks(Y,X), defeated(Y)" states that an argum...

Please sign up or login with your details

Forgot password? Click here to reset