On the Difficulties of Incentivizing Online Privacy through Transparency: A Qualitative Survey of the German Health Insurance Market

11/30/2018
by   Max Maass, et al.
0

Today, online privacy is the domain of regulatory measures and privacy-enhancing technologies. Transparency in the form of external and public assessments has been proposed for improving privacy and security because it exposes otherwise hidden deficiencies. Previous work has studied privacy attitudes and behavior of consumers. However, little is known on how organizations react to measures that employ public "naming and shaming" as an incentive for improvement. We performed the first study on this aspect by conducting a qualitative survey with 152 German health insurers. We scanned their websites with PrivacyScore.org to generate a public ranking and confronted the insurers with the results. We obtained a response rate of 27 Responses ranged from positive feedback to legal threats. Only 12 - mostly non-responders - improved during our study. Our results show that insurers struggle due to unawareness, reluctance, and incapability, and demonstrate the general difficulties of transparency-based approaches.

READ FULL TEXT
research
05/02/2023

SoK: Log Based Transparency Enhancing Technologies

This paper systematizes log based Transparency Enhancing Technologies. B...
research
07/03/2020

Online publication of court records: circumventing the privacy-transparency trade-off

The open data movement is leading to the massive publishing of court rec...
research
03/19/2020

Conducting Privacy-Sensitive Surveys: A Case Study of Civil Society Organizations

Compared to other organizations, civil society organizations (CSOs) ofte...
research
03/27/2021

A Multistakeholder Approach Towards Evaluating AI Transparency Mechanisms

Given that there are a variety of stakeholders involved in, and affected...
research
04/26/2020

PTPARL-D: Annotated Corpus of 44 years of Portuguese Parliament debates

In a representative democracy, some decide in the name of the rest, and ...
research
11/08/2022

Towards Measuring The Fungibility and Anonymity of Cryptocurrencies

Cryptocurrencies aim to replicate physical cash in the digital realm whi...
research
02/20/2018

Relative Worst-Order Analysis: A Survey

Relative worst-order analysis is a technique for assessing the relative ...

Please sign up or login with your details

Forgot password? Click here to reset