On Consequentialism and Fairness

01/02/2020
by   Dallas Card, et al.
11

Recent work on fairness in machine learning has primarily emphasized how to define, quantify, and encourage "fair" outcomes. Less attention has been paid, however, to the ethical foundations which underlie such efforts. Among the ethical perspectives that should be taken into consideration is consequentialism, the position that, roughly speaking, outcomes are all that matter. Although consequentialism is not free from difficulties, and although it does not necessarily provide a tractable way of choosing actions (because of the combined problems of uncertainty, subjectivity, and aggregation), it nevertheless provides a powerful foundation from which to critique the existing literature on machine learning fairness. Moreover, it brings to the fore some of the tradeoffs involved, including the problem of who counts, the pros and cons of using a policy, and the relative value of the distant future. In this paper we provide a consequentialist critique of common definitions of fairness within machine learning, as well as a machine learning perspective on consequentialism. We conclude with a broader discussion of the issues of learning and randomization, which have important implications for the ethics of automated decision making systems.

READ FULL TEXT

page 1

page 2

page 3

page 4

research
05/03/2021

Explaining how your AI system is fair

To implement fair machine learning in a sustainable way, choosing the ri...
research
06/26/2023

Insights From Insurance for Fair Machine Learning: Responsibility, Performativity and Aggregates

We argue that insurance can act as an analogon for the social situatedne...
research
02/25/2022

On Learning and Testing of Counterfactual Fairness through Data Preprocessing

Machine learning has become more important in real-life decision-making ...
research
03/08/2022

The Long Arc of Fairness: Formalisations and Ethical Discourse

In recent years, the idea of formalising and modelling fairness for algo...
research
06/13/2018

What About Applied Fairness?

Machine learning practitioners are often ambivalent about the ethical as...
research
07/22/2022

Verifying Fairness in Quantum Machine Learning

Due to the beyond-classical capability of quantum computing, quantum mac...
research
09/10/2020

A Framework for Fairer Machine Learning in Organizations

With the increase in adoption of machine learning tools by organizations...

Please sign up or login with your details

Forgot password? Click here to reset