Numerical coupling of aerosol emissions, dry removal, and turbulent mixing in the E3SM Atmosphere Model version 1 (EAMv1), part II: a semi-discrete error analysis framework for
share
This paper complements the empirical justification of the revised scheme in Part I of this work with a mathematical justification leveraging a semi-discrete analysis framework for assessing the splitting error of process coupling methods. The novelty of the framework is that splitting error is distinguished from the process time integration errors, i.e., the errors caused by discrete time integration of individual processes, leading to expressions that are more easily interpreted utilizing existing physical understanding of the processes that the terms represent. This application of this framework to dust life cycle in EAMv1 showcases such an interpretation, using the leading-order splitting error that results from the framework to confirm (i) that the original EAMv1 scheme artificially strengthens the effect of dry removal processes, and (ii) that the revised splitting reduces that artificial strengthening. While the error analysis framework is presented in the context of the dust life cycle in EAMv1, the framework can be broadly leveraged to evaluate process coupling schemes, both in other physical problems and for any number of processes. This framework will be particularly powerful when the various process implementations support a variety of time integration approaches. Whereas traditional local truncation error approaches require separate consideration of each combination of time integration methods, this framework enables evaluation of coupling schemes independent of particular time integration approaches for each process while still allowing for the incorporation of these specific time integration errors if so desired. The framework also explains how the splitting error terms result from (i) the integration of individual processes in isolation from other processes, and (ii) the choices of input state and timestep size for the isolated integration of processes.
READ FULL TEXT
