MuRS: Mutant Ranking and Suppression using Identifier Templates
share
Diff-based mutation testing is a mutation testing approach that only mutates lines affected by a code change under review. Google's mutation testing service integrates diff-based mutation testing into the code review process and continuously gathers developer feedback on mutants surfaced during code review. To enhance the developer experience, the mutation testing service implements a number of suppression rules, which target not-useful mutants-that is, mutants that have consistently received negative developer feedback. However, while effective, manually implementing suppression rules require significant engineering time. An automatic system to rank and suppress mutants would facilitate the maintenance of the mutation testing service. This paper proposes and evaluates MuRS, an automated approach that groups mutants by patterns in the source code under test and uses these patterns to rank and suppress future mutants based on historical developer feedback on mutants in the same group. To evaluate MuRS, we conducted an A/B testing study, comparing MuRS to the existing mutation testing service. Despite the strong baseline, which uses manually developed suppression rules, the results show a statistically significantly lower negative feedback ratio of 11.45 for the baseline. The results also show that MuRS is able to recover existing suppression rules implemented in the baseline. Finally, the results show that statement-deletion mutant groups received both the most positive and negative developer feedback, suggesting a need for additional context that can distinguish between useful and not-useful mutants in these groups. Overall, MuRS has the potential to substantially reduce the development and maintenance cost for an effective mutation testing service by automatically learning suppression rules.
READ FULL TEXT
