More crime in cities? On the scaling laws of crime and the inadequacy of per capita rankings – a cross-country study

12/30/2020
by   Marcos Oliveira, et al.
0

Objectives: To evaluate the relationship between population size and number of crimes in cities across twelve countries and assess the impact of per capita measurements on crime analyses, depending on offense type. Methods: We use data on burglaries and thefts at the city level and evaluate the relationship between crime numbers and population size using probabilistic scaling analysis. We estimate the growth exponent of each offense type and use Kendall rank correlation to assess the impact of a linear growth assumption (i.e., per-capita analysis) on cities rankings. Result: In nine out of eleven countries, theft increases superlinearly with population size; in two of them, it increases linearly. In eight out of ten countries, burglary increases linearly with population size; in two of them, it increases superlinearly. In nonlinear scenarios, using per capita rates to rank cities produces substantially different rankings from rankings adjusted for population size. Conclusions: Comparing cities using per capita crime rates (e.g., crime per 100,000 people per year) assumes that crime increases linearly with population size. Our findings indicate, however, that this assumption is unfounded, implying that one should be cautious when using per capita rankings. When crime increases nonlinearly with population, per capita rates do not remove population effects. The contrasting crime growth of burglary and theft also suggests that different crime dynamics at the local level lead to different macro-level features in cities.

READ FULL TEXT
research
04/21/2020

Rankings of countries based on rankings of universities

Although many methods have been designed for ranking universities, there...
research
10/04/2018

Descoberta de relações alométricas entre população e crime dentro de uma grande metrópole

Recently humanity has just crossed an important landmark in its history ...
research
05/10/2021

Similarities between Arabic Dialects: Investigating Geographical Proximity

The automatic classification of Arabic dialects is an ongoing research c...
research
01/01/2022

On income inequality and population size

The pursuit of having an appropriate level of income inequality should b...
research
12/23/2019

Quantifying the Effects of the 2008 Recession using the Zillow Dataset

This report explores the use of Zillow's housing metrics dataset to inve...
research
09/18/2022

On the existence of Scaling laws across Indian districts: A new prospect for urban scaling

Urban scaling analysis in generally performed based on cities. In this s...
research
03/18/2023

Detect influential points of feature rankings

Background Deriving feature rankings is essential in bioinformatics stud...

Please sign up or login with your details

Forgot password? Click here to reset