Monolithic vs. hybrid controller for multi-objective Sim-to-Real learning

08/17/2021
by   Atakan Dag, et al.
0

Simulation to real (Sim-to-Real) is an attractive approach to construct controllers for robotic tasks that are easier to simulate than to analytically solve. Working Sim-to-Real solutions have been demonstrated for tasks with a clear single objective such as "reach the target". Real world applications, however, often consist of multiple simultaneous objectives such as "reach the target" but "avoid obstacles". A straightforward solution in the context of reinforcement learning (RL) is to combine multiple objectives into a multi-term reward function and train a single monolithic controller. Recently, a hybrid solution based on pre-trained single objective controllers and a switching rule between them was proposed. In this work, we compare these two approaches in the multi-objective setting of a robot manipulator to reach a target while avoiding an obstacle. Our findings show that the training of a hybrid controller is easier and obtains a better success-failure trade-off than a monolithic controller. The controllers trained in simulator were verified by a real set-up.

READ FULL TEXT

page 1

page 5

page 6

research
07/26/2023

Evolving Multi-Objective Neural Network Controllers for Robot Swarms

Many swarm robotics tasks consist of multiple conflicting objectives. Th...
research
03/29/2019

Stable, Concurrent Controller Composition for Multi-Objective Robotic Tasks

Robotic systems often need to consider multiple tasks concurrently. This...
research
02/14/2019

Multi-Objective Policy Generation for Multi-Robot Systems Using Riemannian Motion Policies

In the multi-robot systems literature, control policies are typically ob...
research
01/04/2017

Estimating Quality in Multi-Objective Bandits Optimization

Many real-world applications are characterized by a number of conflictin...
research
05/26/2023

MULTIGAIN 2.0: MDP controller synthesis for multiple mean-payoff, LTL and steady-state constraints

We present MULTIGAIN 2.0, a major extension to the controller synthesis ...
research
01/23/2020

Impact-aware humanoid robot motion generation with a quadratic optimization controller

Impact-aware tasks (i.e. on purpose impacts) are not handled in multi-ob...
research
04/25/2020

On the Generalization Capability of Evolved Counter-propagation Neuro-controllers for Robot Navigation

Evolving Counter-Propagation Neuro-Controllers (CPNCs), rather than the ...

Please sign up or login with your details

Forgot password? Click here to reset