Latent Space Modeling of Multidimensional Networks with Application to the Exchange of Votes in Eurovision Song Contest

03/13/2018
by   Silvia D'Angelo, et al.
0

The Eurovision Song Contest is a popular TV singing competition held annually among country members of the European Broadcasting Union. In this competition, each member can be both contestant and jury, as it can participate with a song and/or vote for other countries' tunes. Throughout the years, the voting system has repeatedly been accused of being biased by the presence of tactical voting, according to which votes would represent strategic interests rather than actual musical preferences of the voting countries. In this work, we develop a latent space model to investigate the presence of a latent structure underlying the exchange of votes. Focusing on the period from 1998 to 2015, we represent the vote exchange as a multivariate network: each edition is a network, where countries are the nodes and two countries are linked by an edge if one voted for the other. The different networks are taken to be independent replicates of a common latent space capturing the overall relationships among the countries. Proximity denotes similarity, and countries close in the latent space are assumed to be more likely to exchange votes. Therefore, if the exchange of votes depends on the similarity between countries, the quality of the competing songs might not be a relevant factor in the determination of the voting preferences, and this would suggest the presence of bias. A Bayesian hierarchical modelling approach is employed to model the probability of a connection between any two countries as a function of their distance in the latent space, and of network-specific parameters and edge-specific covariates. The inferred latent space is found to be relevant in the determination of edge probabilities, however, the positions of the countries in such space only partially correspond to their actual geographical positions.

READ FULL TEXT

page 25

page 26

page 39

page 40

research
07/16/2018

Modeling the social media relationships of Irish politicians using a generalized latent space stochastic blockmodel

Dáil Éireann is the principal chamber of the Irish parliament. The 31st ...
research
05/26/2012

On latent position inference from doubly stochastic messaging activities

We model messaging activities as a hierarchical doubly stochastic point ...
research
12/28/2020

Latent space models for multiplex networks with shared structure

Latent space models are frequently used for modeling single-layer networ...
research
06/05/2023

Media Bias and Polarization through the Lens of a Markov Switching Latent Space Network Model

News outlets are now more than ever incentivized to provide their audien...
research
06/18/2012

Manifold Relevance Determination

In this paper we present a fully Bayesian latent variable model which ex...
research
03/18/2018

A Dynamic Additive and Multiplicative Effects Model with Application to the United Nations Voting Behaviors

In this paper, we introduce a statistical regression model for discrete-...
research
05/30/2023

Dynamic Factor Models for Binary Data in Circular Spaces: An Application to the U.S. Supreme Court

Latent factor models are widely used in the social and behavioral scienc...

Please sign up or login with your details

Forgot password? Click here to reset