DeepAI AI Chat
Log In Sign Up

Inverse Dynamics vs. Forward Dynamics in Direct Transcription Formulations for Trajectory Optimization

by   Henrique Ferrolho, et al.

Benchmarks of state-of-the-art rigid-body dynamics libraries have reported better performance for solving the inverse dynamics problem than the forward alternative. Those benchmarks encouraged us to question whether this computational advantage translates to direct transcription formulations, where calculating the rigid-body dynamics and their derivatives often accounts for a significant share of computation time. In this work, we implement an optimization framework where both approaches for enforcing the system dynamics are available. We evaluate the performance of each approach for systems of varying complexity, and for domains with rigid contacts. Our tests revealed that formulations employing inverse dynamics converge faster, require less iterations, and are more robust to coarse problem discretization. These results suggest that inverse dynamics should be the preferred approach to enforce nonlinear system dynamics in simultaneous methods, such as direct transcription.


page 1

page 5

page 8


Details of Second-Order Partial Derivatives of Rigid-Body Inverse Dynamics

This document provides full details of second-order partial derivatives ...

Direct multiple shooting and direct collocation perform similarly in biomechanical predictive simulations

Direct multiple shooting (DMS) and direct collocation (DC) are two commo...

GRiD: GPU-Accelerated Rigid Body Dynamics with Analytical Gradients

We introduce GRiD: a GPU-accelerated library for computing rigid body dy...

Efficient solution method based on inverse dynamics for optimal control problems of rigid body systems

We propose an efficient way of solving optimal control problems for rigi...

RBDCore: Robot Rigid Body Dynamics Accelerator with Multifunctional Pipelines

Rigid body dynamics is a key technology in the robotics field. In trajec...

A Unified Method for Solving Inverse, Forward, and Hybrid Manipulator Dynamics using Factor Graphs

This paper describes a unified method solving for inverse, forward, and ...