Intrinsic Argument Strength in Structured Argumentation: a Principled Approach

by   Jeroen Paul Spaans, et al.

Abstract argumentation provides us with methods such as gradual and Dung semantics with which to evaluate arguments after potential attacks by other arguments. Some of these methods can take intrinsic strengths of arguments as input, with which to modulate the effects of attacks between arguments. Coming from abstract argumentation, these methods look only at the relations between arguments and not at the structure of the arguments themselves. In structured argumentation the way an argument is constructed, by chaining inference rules starting from premises, is taken into consideration. In this paper we study methods for assigning an argument its intrinsic strength, based on the strengths of the premises and inference rules used to form said argument. We first define a set of principles, which are properties that strength assigning methods might satisfy. We then propose two such methods and analyse which principles they satisfy. Finally, we present a generalised system for creating novel strength assigning methods and speak to the properties of this system regarding the proposed principles.



page 1

page 2

page 3

page 4


The Inverse Problem for Argumentation Gradual Semantics

Gradual semantics with abstract argumentation provide each argument with...

An Approach to Characterize Graded Entailment of Arguments through a Label-based Framework

Argumentation theory is a powerful paradigm that formalizes a type of co...

Before Name-calling: Dynamics and Triggers of Ad Hominem Fallacies in Web Argumentation

Arguing without committing a fallacy is one of the main requirements of ...

Argument Ranking with Categoriser Function

Recently, ranking-based semantics is proposed to rank-order arguments fr...

Dealing with Incompatibilities among Procedural Goals under Uncertainty

By considering rational agents, we focus on the problem of selecting goa...

Impact of Argument Type and Concerns in Argumentation with a Chatbot

Conversational agents, also known as chatbots, are versatile tools that ...

The Effect of Preferences in Abstract Argumentation Under a Claim-Centric View

In this paper, we study the effect of preferences in abstract argumentat...
This week in AI

Get the week's most popular data science and artificial intelligence research sent straight to your inbox every Saturday.