Instrumental Variables with Treatment-Induced Selection: Exact Bias Results

05/19/2020
by   Felix Elwert, et al.
0

Instrumental variables (IV) estimation suffers selection bias when the analysis conditions on the treatment. Judea Pearl's early graphical definition of instrumental variables explicitly prohibited conditioning on the treatment. Nonetheless, the practice remains common. In this paper, we derive exact analytic expressions for IV selection bias across a range of data-generating models, and for various selection-inducing procedures. We present four sets of results for linear models. First, IV selection bias depends on the conditioning procedure (covariate adjustment vs. sample truncation). Second, IV selection bias due to covariate adjustment is the limiting case of IV selection bias due to sample truncation. Third, in certain models, the IV and OLS estimators under selection bound the true causal effect in large samples. Fourth, we characterize situations where IV remains preferred to OLS despite selection on the treatment. These results broaden the notion of IV selection bias beyond sample truncation, replace prior simulation findings with exact analytic formulas, and enable formal sensitivity analyses.

READ FULL TEXT
research
06/21/2023

Learning Conditional Instrumental Variable Representation for Causal Effect Estimation

One of the fundamental challenges in causal inference is to estimate the...
research
11/07/2017

Adjusting for bias introduced by instrumental variable estimation in the Cox Proportional Hazards Model

Instrumental variable (IV) methods are widely used for estimating averag...
research
11/20/2019

Instrumental Variables: to Strengthen or not to Strengthen?

Instrumental variables (IV) are extensively used to estimate treatment e...
research
03/15/2012

On a Class of Bias-Amplifying Variables that Endanger Effect Estimates

This note deals with a class of variables that, if conditioned on, tends...
research
07/16/2021

Clarifying Selection Bias in Cluster Randomized Trials: Estimands and Estimation

In cluster randomized trials, patients are recruited after clusters are ...
research
06/17/2021

Causal Bias Quantification for Continuous Treatment

In this work we develop a novel characterization of marginal causal effe...
research
04/09/2021

A Case Study of Nonresponse Bias Analysis

Nonresponse bias is a widely prevalent problem for data collections. We ...

Please sign up or login with your details

Forgot password? Click here to reset