DeepAI AI Chat
Log In Sign Up

Incidental or influential? - Challenges in automatically detecting citation importance using publication full texts

by   David Pride, et al.
The Open University

This work looks in depth at several studies that have attempted to automate the process of citation importance classification based on the publications full text. We analyse a range of features that have been previously used in this task. Our experimental results confirm that the number of in text references are highly predictive of influence. Contrary to the work of Valenzuela et al. we find abstract similarity one of the most predictive features. Overall, we show that many of the features previously described in literature are not particularly predictive. Consequently, we discuss challenges and potential improvements in the classification pipeline, provide a critical review of the performance of individual features and address the importance of constructing a large scale gold standard reference dataset.


page 1

page 2

page 3

page 4


Highly cited references in PLOS ONE and their in-text usage over time

In this article, we describe highly cited publications in a PLOS ONE ful...

A Natural Language Processing Pipeline for Detecting Informal Data References in Academic Literature

Discovering authoritative links between publications and the datasets th...

Reference String Extraction Using Line-Based Conditional Random Fields

The extraction of individual reference strings from the reference sectio...

Interdisciplinarity metric based on the co-citation network

Quantifying the interdisciplinarity of a research is a relevant problem ...

unarXive 2022: All arXiv Publications Pre-Processed for NLP, Including Structured Full-Text and Citation Network

Large-scale data sets on scholarly publications are the basis for a vari...

Towards Generating Citation Sentences for Multiple References with Intent Control

Machine-generated citation sentences can aid automated scientific litera...

The State of Open Access in Germany: An Analysis of the Publication Output of German Universities

Starting with the Berlin declaration in 2003, Open Access (OA) publishin...