In Search of Outstanding Research Advances: Prototyping the creation of an open dataset of "editorial highlights"

by   Alexis-Michel Mugabushaka, et al.

A long-standing research question in bibliometrics is how one identifies publications, which represent major advances in their fields, making high impact in there and other areas. In this context, the term "Breakthrough" is often used and commonly used approaches rely on citation links between publications implicitly positing that peers who use or build upon previously published results collectively inform about their standing in terms of advancing the research frontiers. Here we argue that the "Breakthrough" concept is rooted in the Kuhnian model of scientific revolution which has been both conceptually and empirically challenged. A more fruitful approach is to consider various ways in which authoritative actors in scholarly communication system signal the importance of research results. We bring to discussions different "recognition channels" and pilot the creation of an open dataset of editorial highlights from regular lists of notable research advances. The dataset covers the last ten years and includes: the "discoveries of the year" from Science magazine and La Recherche and weekly editorial highlights from Nature ("research highlights") and Science ("editor's choice"). The final dataset includes 230 entries in the "discoveries of the years" (with over 720 references) and about 9,000 weekly highlights (with over 8,000 references).


The number of linked references of publications in Microsoft Academic in comparison with the Web of Science

In the context of a comprehensive Microsoft Academic (MA) study, we expl...

The geography of references in elite articles: What countries contribute to the archives of knowledge

This study is intended to find an answer for the question on which natio...

A Natural Language Processing Pipeline for Detecting Informal Data References in Academic Literature

Discovering authoritative links between publications and the datasets th...

Attention: to Better Stand on the Shoulders of Giants

Science of science (SciSci) is an emerging discipline wherein science is...

Does publicity in the science press drive citations? A vindication of peer review

We study how publicity, in the form of highlighting in the science press...

Global research collaboration: Networks and partners in South East Asia

This is an empirical paper that addresses the role of bilateral and mult...