DeepAI AI Chat
Log In Sign Up

Imperfect fifths pack into musical scales

by   John M. McBride, et al.
proton mail

Musical scales are used in cultures throughout the world, but the question as to how they evolved remains open. Some suggest that scales based on the harmonic series are inherently pleasant, while others propose that scales are chosen that are easy to sing, hear and reproduce accurately. However, testing these theories has been hindered by the sparseness of empirical evidence. Here, to enable such examination, we assimilate data from diverse ethnomusicological sources into a cross-cultural database of scales. We generate populations of scales based on proposed and alternative theories and assess their similarity to empirical distributions from the database. Most scales can be explained as tending to include intervals roughly corresponding to perfect fifths ("imperfect fifths"), and packing arguments explain the salient features of the distributions. Scales are also preferred if their intervals are compressible, which could facilitate efficient communication and memory of melodies. While no single theory can explain all scales, which appear to evolve according to different selection pressures, the simplest harmonicity-based, imperfect-fifths packing model best fits the empirical data.


page 10

page 13


Analysis of the Harmonic Function Used in Bin-Packing

The harmonic function was first introduced by Lee and Lee (JACM 1985) fo...

General Theory of Music by Icosahedron 3: Musical invariant and Melakarta raga

Raga is a central musical concept in South Asia, especially India, and w...

Moving intervals for packing and covering

We study several problems on geometric packing and covering with movemen...

Harmonic Complex Networks

We report the possibility of obtaining complex networks with diverse top...

Rock, Rap, or Reggaeton?: Assessing Mexican Immigrants' Cultural Assimilation Using Facebook Data

The degree to which Mexican immigrants in the U.S. are assimilating cult...

Expectations over Unspoken Alternatives Predict Pragmatic Inferences

Scalar inferences (SI) are a signature example of how humans interpret l...

And what if two musical versions don't share melody, harmony, rhythm, or lyrics ?

Version identification (VI) has seen substantial progress over the past ...